We must applaud Thol Thirumavalavans stand on Manusmriti. BJP attacking the messenger – ThePrint
Posted: November 7, 2020 at 3:59 am
Text Size: A- A+
The recent controversy over Viduthalai Chiruthaigal Katchi leader Thol Thirumavalavans remarks on the demeaning portrayal of women in the Manusmriti has already accomplished two things. First, it has shined a light on the rampant sexism practiced by many of our political leaders, who sanctimoniously claim to support womens equality. Second, the ill-informed response by the Bharatiya Janata Partys Khushbu Sundar has exposed the hypocrisy of her organisation, one of whose leaders only recently declared that the men accused of the heinous rape in Hathras are innocentand that the murdered woman was an awaara.
I found nothing offensive in Thirumavalavans remarks, which were only highlighting the offensive verses from the Manusmriti. However, his call to ban the text brought two anecdotes to my mind.
Some years back, when I had broached the subject of Manusmritiwith a family priest, he had declared with an air of finality, Everything was fine in our society until we stopped following Manu. He had earlier turned down a request from a woman wishing to perform ceremonies for her departed father, saying that he could only officiate if a person could sit bare-chested and with apoonal(sacred thread).
Onanotheroccasion, while visiting the Melukote temple nearMysuru, I had questioned apujariabout the tradition that allows the local Dalit community to take over the sanctum once a year (supposedly instituted by Ramanuja over 800 years ago). He didnt sound too happy: What can I say. These days they come in anytime they please. My father later informed me that after the Dalits designated day of worship, the priests purify the temple before resuming puja.
Also read: Dont listen to VHP and panic. Christianity is a failed project in India
I recount these exchanges to underscore thatManusmritiis still alive and well in the minds of large sections of our society and banning it is not going to banish bigotry from their minds.
What is desperately needed is a movement to reinvent Hinduism with urgent focus on eliminating gender and caste discrimination, perhaps taking cues from early rebelssuch asAkka Mahadevi, Basavanna, Kabir, and many others. Sadly, most Hindu religious leaders today seem unequal to the task. At best, they say that they themselves do not discriminate; at worst, they are too busy locking arms with Hindunationalists in their triumphalism over Indias Muslims and Christians to care about the real state of Hinduism today.
Privileged urban middle-class Hindus, on the other hand, will often declare that an end to the caste system will come soon enough through generational changes. Unfortunately, there is little evidence of such change among the younger generations, even as caste-related and sexual violence are on the rise. Recent news reports of wide-spread caste bias inSilicon Valley challenge the very notion that we can simply sit back and let our future generations bring an end to casteism over time.
On another side of the caste debate, some will ridicule the very notion that Hinduism is capable of reform, suggesting that the only way to annihilate caste is to annihilate Hinduism. Such strident voices coming from historically oppressed communities are understandable, but are completely unrealistic and offer no practical pathways to eliminating the caste system.
Finally, Hindu nationalists have never hadsocialreforms on their agenda. Instead, their priority has always been to portray themselves as the sole defenders of the Hindu faith from its external enemies.
No one could have put it more succinctly than my childhood friend and a senior Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) ideologue from Bengaluru who once told me that dealing with the Muslim problem and Christian conversions were his top priorities. We can address our internal family problems later, he had said. Why wash our dirty linen in public?
Hindu nationalists have not changed much since that conversationI had decades ago, except that name-calling, intimidation, and violence have now become a major part of their portfolio.
In the meantime, their obfuscations and conspiracy theories are finding newer audiences, thanks to WhatsApp and coordinated Hindutva messaging like Manusmiti is mostly forged and is the work of enemies of Hinduism; Varnashrama and the caste system are distinctly different; our scriptures do not mention caste, which was imposed by Islamic and British rulers.
Also read: Whose Ram Rajya does Ayodhya temple bring Gandhis or Modis? Ambedkar can answer
In the United States, Hindunationalists have a unique dilemma. They want to avoid any honest discussion of the caste system and theManusmiti, but they also want to be seen as allies in the fight for racial and gender equality. As a result, they spend an inordinate amount of time arguing that caste and race are not at all comparable and that the Manusmitihas nothing to do with Hinduism. And they fully exploit the multi-cultural-friendly school systems to demand that the State protect the sensibilities of their children by not portraying the caste system in a negative light and by not discussing the oppression of women and Dalits.
It must irk them greatly today that the Black Lives Matter movement is eliciting many parallelsbetween the civil rights struggle and the continuing struggle of Dalits for equality.
Honesty and soul-searching have never been part of the Hindutva character. But the late learned Chandrasekarendra Sarasvati, the highly respected Kanchi Sankaracharya, had no qualms about telling it like it is:
According to the sastras, the Hindu community is divided into various castes. A particular duty is assigned to a particular caste. By heredity people come into a casteIt is the duty of other caste people to look after the Brahmins.
1963 interview with Prof. J.W. Elder of Universityof Wisconsin
He also went on to say that India being a secular State, it is the responsibility of religious leaders and institutions to see to the moral and religious uplift of society. Unfortunately, most such leaders, today,are utterly failing in those responsibilities by aligning themselves with an authoritarian and brutal ruling political class. I see no morality or religious upliftment in that.
Also read: Black lives mattered to Phule and Ambedkar. They had seen caste discrimination in India
The fact of the matter is that like other religions of the world, Hinduism, too, has a legacy of the good, the bad, and the really ugly. Hindus must own it all first, before we can have an honest conversation about how to bring about real changes. And that conversation must begin by personally disavowing the ugly at every opportunity we get.
WhenBhimraoAmbedkar burnt the text of theManusmritiin 1927, he was assisted by a Muslim and a Brahmin, who saw his symbolic act for what it was an act of resistance to raise societys consciousness about the fundamental inequities of Hinduism.
We must applaud Thirumavalavan for reminding us 93 years later that those inequities are still continuing. The difference, however, is that the Dalit movements today can count on many more non-Dalit allies by their side as they carry forward their struggle for equality.
By attacking the messenger,theBJP has shown its desperation to look for a wedge issue in an innately secular TamilNadu.
Raju Rajagopal is co-founder of Hindus for Human Rights @Hndus4HR. Views are personal.
Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram
Why news media is in crisis & How you can fix it
India needs free, fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism even more as it faces multiple crises.
But the news media is in a crisis of its own. There have been brutal layoffs and pay-cuts. The best of journalism is shrinking, yielding to crude prime-time spectacle.
ThePrint has the finest young reporters, columnists and editors working for it. Sustaining journalism of this quality needs smart and thinking people like you to pay for it. Whether you live in India or overseas, you can do it here.
Support Our Journalism
Read the original:
We must applaud Thol Thirumavalavans stand on Manusmriti. BJP attacking the messenger - ThePrint
- 5 booked for torching house of family that converted to Hinduism in UPs Raebareli - Hindustan Times - January 5th, 2021
- Warping a great faith: Both hard and soft Hindutva are expedient uses of religion for political ga - The Times of India Blog - January 5th, 2021
- Reflecting on Hinduism as a Religion and a Way of Life ! - Star of Mysore - January 5th, 2021
- Reflecting on Hinduism as a Religion: A good read - Star of Mysore - January 5th, 2021
- Uttar Pradesh: Muslim mans family reverts to Hinduism in Rae Bareli, members of madarsa, village head try to burn them alive - OpIndia - January 5th, 2021
- Al-Biruni and Hindu-Muslim Relations: Lessons from Malaysia - The Wire - January 5th, 2021
- Lincoln County Commission to open with Hindu prayers at upcoming meeting - Lincoln County Record - January 5th, 2021
- The Hindu gods of Buddhist Thailand - Nepali times - January 5th, 2021
- India deals another blow to religious freedom - Mission Network News - January 5th, 2021
- Govt's Agri-Export Promotion Body Drops 'Halal' From Its Red Meat Manual After Outrage By Hindus, Sikhs - Swarajya - January 5th, 2021
- Redefining Aurangzeb...more sinned against than sinning - Free Press Journal - January 5th, 2021
- From the Dara Hua Hindus of Maujpur to Manavs tragic death and Shaheen Bagh ground report: Top 10 exclusive OpIndia news breaks of 2020 - OpIndia - January 5th, 2021
- UN urged to probe killing of Pakistani Hindus in India - The News International - January 5th, 2021
- Govt of India removes the word Halal from its Red Meat Manual: Here is what it means - OpIndia - January 5th, 2021
- The religious composition of the 117th Congress | Pew Research Center - Pew Research Center's Religion and Public Life Project - January 5th, 2021
- Hinduism - Wikipedia - December 17th, 2020
- Hinduism | Origin, History, Beliefs, Gods, & Facts ... - December 17th, 2020
- Persecution of religious minorities continue in Pakistan as Islamists attack homes of Hindus in Sindh, forcing them to leave - OpIndia - December 17th, 2020
- Hindu religion was never so narrow: Karnataka HC dismisses pleas seeking strict implementation of section of Act that requires Temple officials to be... - December 17th, 2020
- Faith: What if Jesus had not incarnated? - Kamloops This Week - December 17th, 2020
- Hindus beat pastor in India, threaten to sacrifice him to false god over Bible tracts - The Christian Post - December 17th, 2020
- Letters to the Editor - Sentinelassam - The Sentinel Assam - December 17th, 2020
- It is 2020 and Mullah Mulayams son Akhilesh has turned Ram Bhakt: Read Samajwadi Partys history of insulting Hindu sentiments - OpIndia - December 17th, 2020
- Punjab Of The 1980s: Nehruvian Laboratory Versus Healing Hindutva - Swarajya - December 17th, 2020
- BJP repeating Congress blunders of dividing Sikhs and Hindus in Punjab: Akali Dal - Sikh24 News & Updates - December 17th, 2020
- A New Central Vista, and the Political Conceit of the Ruling Classes - The Wire - December 17th, 2020
- If Modi really sees India as a democracy, then he must stop the labelling exercise - ThePrint - December 17th, 2020
- Hinduism, like many great religions, is about feasting and fasting, praying and eating prasadam - Cond Nast Traveller India - November 25th, 2020
- KTR should also question Akbar on his hatred towards Hindus: Vijayashanti - The Hindu - November 25th, 2020
- Not Ram Mandir, the love jihad laws are the foundation of Hindu Rashtra - ThePrint - November 25th, 2020
- UP Police Investigation of 'Love Jihad' Concludes What We Already Know -- It Doesn't Exist - The Swaddle - November 25th, 2020
- Biased Media Reporting in India Helps Fuel the Persecution of Christians - International Christian Concern - November 25th, 2020
- Banning Fireworks on Diwali: A Window Into Money and Politics in India - The Diplomat - November 25th, 2020
- Lawyer writes to PM, urging the addition of Section 493A in IPC to stop conversion and love jihad - India Legal - November 25th, 2020
- 10 Stereotypes Indians Are Tired Of Seeing In Western Films And TV - Screen Rant - November 25th, 2020
- Muslims react with caution to UP govt's ordinance against conversion for marriage - Mint - November 25th, 2020
- Yogendra Yadav is wrong to assume Owaisis AIMIM will be a Muslim BJP - ThePrint - November 25th, 2020
- 1,300-Year-Old Hindu Temple Dedicated to God Vishnu Discovered in Northwest Pakistan's Swat - India.com - November 25th, 2020
- Hindus in N.J. who voted for Trump in 2016 say their support is waning - nj.com - November 7th, 2020
- India takes up with Bangladesh attack on Hindus - The Hindu - November 7th, 2020
- Congress urges Centre to take up with Bangladesh attacks on Hindus - The Hindu - November 7th, 2020
- Adhir tells Centre to raise issue of violence against Hindus in Bangladesh - The Indian Express - November 7th, 2020
- Jihad in Hinduism, Bible and Torah | KashmirWatch - Kashmir Watch - November 7th, 2020
- Mathura: Four Hindus arrested after reciting Hanuman Chalisa in Eidgah Masjid to promote brotherhood - OpIndia - November 7th, 2020
- Gandhi Land Scam; Dhaka Hindus attacked for backing France? | Nation Wants To Know - Times Now - November 7th, 2020
- Etsy removes Sexy Ganesh Panties within few hours of Hindu protest - NewsPatrolling - November 7th, 2020
- Dear Maneka Gandhi, attempts to curb animal sacrifice is a direct assault on Hindu Dharma and it is time to stop such efforts - OpIndia - November 7th, 2020
- Dalits & Religious Conversion: Tracing The History Of The Neo-Buddhist Movement - Feminism in India - November 7th, 2020
- 'Tribals are Hindus, don't divide them' - Daily Pioneer - November 7th, 2020
- Heres Why Ban Laxmmi Movie Is Trending On Twitter - SheThePeople - November 7th, 2020
- Samir Kalra on Islamists and Hinduphobia in America - Middle East Forum - November 7th, 2020
- Why dont we give credit to Hindu festivals for reviving the economy? - OpIndia - November 7th, 2020
- Navaratri and how Indic religions are intrinsically federal - The New Indian Express - October 31st, 2020
- Interview: Romila Thapar on the history of dissent and how it shaped Hinduism and India - Scroll.in - October 31st, 2020
- Fraternity in the basic spirit of Hinduism - Avenue Mail - October 31st, 2020
- Pakistan: Homes of Hindus burnt down by Islamists in Sindh to force them to convert to Islam - OpIndia - October 31st, 2020
- How Hindu Nationalism Could Shape the Election - POLITICO - October 31st, 2020
- 'Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi, Shahnawaz Hussains wives are Hindus; is this love jihad', asks Digvijaya Singh - Times Now - October 31st, 2020
- Plea in SC seeks SIT probe into 'forceful conversion' of Hindus in Haryana's Nuh - The New Indian Express - October 31st, 2020
- Election 2020 Preview, Hinduism 101, India and the Role of Indian Americans in US Elections With Ramesh Kapur - India New England - October 31st, 2020
- IAS Officer Ritika Jindals Interference In Maa Shoolini Temple Rituals Shows Why Hindus Must Oppose Government Control Of Temples - Swarajya - October 31st, 2020
- Ramayana retold: Here are some of the most popular versions of the epic - Financial Express - October 31st, 2020
- University of Sydney to seriously look into article in its paper ridiculing Hinduism - NewsPatrolling - October 31st, 2020
- Hindus urge Malta government to subsidise cremation abroad - Times of Malta - October 31st, 2020
- Muslim-Hindu demography of Jammu and Kashmir: What the Census numbers show - The Indian Express - October 31st, 2020