Rethinking Our Concepts of Disability to Meet Our Changing Social Worlds – James Moore
Posted: September 3, 2020 at 3:56 pm
A paper published recently in the Journal of Medical Ethics explores the relationship between disability and enhancement, and the importance of social context and environment in how they get defined. According to the group of authors, led by Nicholas Greig Evans, a Professor of Philosophy at the University of Massachusetts Lowell, the most popular ways of thinking about disability and impairment often either discount certain types of disability or patronize the person with the impairment.
Going further, the authors explain how popular accounts tend to ignore how social stereotypes about disability can impact even those who do not identify as disabled or impaired themselves:
There have been many different models of disability proposed over time, ranging from models based on social factors and human rights to those that link disability to technology. Recent events, like the Covid-19 pandemic and the associated economic and climate disasters, moreover, serve as ongoing reminders of how our abilities to act freely as individuals are always shaped by the broader socioeconomic dimensions of our lives. This insight echoes what critical psychologists have been saying for decades.
According to Evans and the other authors, most people thinking seriously about these issues agree that disability is a widely heterogeneous set of phenomena, so much so, they note that some have argued it to be a meaningless category in the abstract. For them, most existing models dont account for the way assumptions about disability are intertwined with assumptions about enhancement, insofar as both are shaped by which skills happen to be considered most valuable in a given social setting.
How we define either disability or enhancement, they propose, depends on how we compare the behaviors of a specific individual with a statistically relevant cohort group. Cohort group studies track changes in behavior and expressed capacities over time across individuals who live under similar conditions.
With this in mind, the authors suggest it could be useful to think about human abilities in general in terms of the concept of capacity space, which they define as the dynamic relationship between an individual person and their social and environmental milieu. From this perspective, phenomena we tend to call disability are inherently dynamic because they change over time, and they are relational because they are constituted through interactions between persons and the social tools (e.g., digital technology) they have available.
The concept of capacity space, the authors propose, provides a useful starting point for understanding the full variability and breadth of disability as a ubiquitous characteristic of the human species. To help illustrate this, they present a series of case studies that depict experiences of disability and enhancement that are often overlooked in the literature.
For example, they point to certain dysgenic effects in soldiers after WWI, where a high number of casualties left young men who were previously considered physically unfit among the only individuals available for military service.
In this instance, individuals who had been considered disabled relative to other soldiers before the war could have become normal, or even enhanced, simply because the cohort group against which they were judged had changed. This, the authors explain, is an example of how ones capacity space can be transformed even when ones individual abilities remain relatively consistent.
Another example they discuss is the many different variations of chronic pain. This is true both within the same individual as well as across different individuals. Some days are, of course, better than others, with factors ranging from diet, climate, and social contact, possibly having some effect on how chronic pain is experienced and managed at any given time.
Symptoms related to a diagnosis of Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (EDS), a hypermobility condition, for instance, might be relatively mild when compared to other individuals who are diagnosed with the same condition:
Thinking about disability as something that any human can experience under the right set of conditions, and in entirely personal ways, represents a clear departure from approaches like welfarism, which posits a clearly defined line between disability and ability.
The authors define welfarist approaches to disability as those that posit a stable physiological or psychological property of a subject S that leads to a significant reduction of Ss level of well-being in some circumstance. From this perspective, disability is defined not according to how an individual can perform socially, but according to how the individuals sense of well-being is impacted by one of their personal traits.
Enhancement, by contrast, would be defined under welfarism by any stable property of a person that leads to a significant increase in that persons well-being. By focusing on psychological well-being, rather than social structures or medical status, the authors suggest, welfarist approaches to disability and enhancement account for something important that other models tend to ignore.
And yet, by framing disability as something intrinsic to each individual person, and defining welfare solely in terms of well-being, welfarist accounts risk marginalizing the consequences of prejudice and institutional discrimination for those who do not conform to conventional social expectations. They also fail to adequately account for the ways disabilities have different social implications across time and space, beyond individual well-being.
Such dimensions, the authors claim, are essential to experiences of disability. With their concept of capacity space, they underscore how time and space are not abstract categories; like disability itself, they are complex social realities that shape what individuals consider possible for themselves and others.
The authors are also cautious not to discount sociohistorical accounts of disability. Instead, they describe their project as complementary to such accounts. And yet, the importance of economics and social factors related to race and gender are given relatively little attention in their article.
It is hard to imagine how a cohort, or any other social group, for that matter, could be considered relevant to a persons lived-experience without accounting for the way self-image and self-performance are assigned value today largely in terms of capital.
Under current conditions of global capitalism, social networks are unavoidably shaped by the technologies, information, and capital that its members have access to. Indeed, enhancement and technology are so obviously linked in todays hyperconnected world that it would make little sense to propose a concept of one that cannot account for the other.
While statisticians have the luxury of selecting cohort groups based on analytic convenience, this is not true for those whose embodied natures fail to align with the skills deemed most valuable in todays information-based markets. These are issues that movements like transhumanism and posthumanism have been engaging with for decades, but they are, unfortunately, not given much attention by the authors of this paper.
****
Evans, N. G., Reynolds, J. M., & Johnson, K. R. (2020). Moving through capacity space: Mapping disability and enhancement. Journal of Medical Ethics. (Link)
See original here:
Rethinking Our Concepts of Disability to Meet Our Changing Social Worlds - James Moore
- Transhumanism: Expert exposes liberal billionaire elitists ... - March 9th, 2021
- Transhumanism And The Future Of Humanity: 7 Ways The World ... - March 9th, 2021
- Dr. Carrie Madej: COVID-19 mRNA vaccines are transhumanism ... - March 9th, 2021
- Agenda 21 How Would You Like to be Forced into a Human ... - March 9th, 2021
- The Chronicles of Covid, or why we must kill the Great Reset Witch - The Conservative Woman - February 10th, 2021
- 8 Best Cyberpunk Anime Fans of the Genre Should Watch Nexta - Twinfinite - December 30th, 2020
- Fact check: UK deaths linked to COVID-19 did not stop in June - Reuters - December 5th, 2020
- Beware The Transhumanists: How 'being Human' Is Being Re-engineered By The Elite's Covid-19 Coup - The Nigerian Voice - October 1st, 2020
- Cyberpunk 2077 where did all the punk go? - PCGamesN - October 1st, 2020
- Can we resurrect the dead? Researchers catalogue potential future methods - Big Think - September 23rd, 2020
- CD Projekt Red have nabbed Cyberpunk, but here are 5 other punks that deserve games - PC Gamer - September 23rd, 2020
- The Honorable Dr. Dale Layman, Founder of Robowatch, LLC, is Recognized as the 2020 Humanitarian of the Year by Top 100 Registry, Inc. - IT News... - September 3rd, 2020
- Transhumanism: Meet the cyborgs and biohackers redefining beauty - CNN - May 31st, 2020
- Everything coming to HBO Max in June 2020 - Mashable - May 31st, 2020
- Scientists Just Watched Artificial Neurons 'Speak' to Real Neurons Using Light - ScienceAlert - May 24th, 2020
- Heres Everything Coming to HBO Max in June 2020 - Cord Cutters News, LLC - May 23rd, 2020
- Introducing When the Sparrow Falls, the Debut Novel From Neil Sharpson - tor.com - May 15th, 2020
- Five Essay Collections to Read in Quarantine - Willamette Week - April 24th, 2020
- The Proto-Communist Plan to Resurrect Everyone Who Ever Lived - VICE UK - April 24th, 2020
- Nationalists Claim They Want to Redefine Conservatism, but They're Not Sure What It Is - Foreign Policy - April 17th, 2020
- 'Everyone in the worlds life is falling apart to some greater or lesser degree' - The Irish Times - April 17th, 2020
- Zoltan Istvan: The Transhumanist Candidate - Roads and Kingdoms - March 20th, 2020
- Sleeve Into Altered Carbon: The Role Playing Game - Nerdist - March 20th, 2020
- How Deus Ex: Human Revolution Perfectly Predicts The Future - Fiction Talk - January 22nd, 2020
- The future of implants in the latest Medical Technology - Medical Device Network - January 14th, 2020
- GOP candidate pitches robots and immortality to Iowa voters - The Gazette - December 18th, 2019
- The 2010s were the decade of trans - The Spectator USA - December 18th, 2019
- From Brain Games to the philosophy of the future: Jason Silva - Daily Sabah - December 18th, 2019
- How our screen stories of the future went from flying cars to a darker version of now - The Conversation AU - December 13th, 2019
- Living in the real AI world - Covalence - December 13th, 2019
- New Connections Emerge Between The Clintons And Jeffrey Epstein: Report - The Daily Wire - December 8th, 2019
- Ai-Da, the worlds first ultra-realistic robot artist in conversation with Tim Marlow this week. - FAD magazine - December 8th, 2019
- Meet the Microchipped Transhumanist Cyborg Whos Running Against Trump in the 2020 GOP Primary - Mediaite - November 26th, 2019
- What it means to be a cyborg in 2019 - Quartz - November 21st, 2019
- Raju Foundation Essay Contest Winner On the Ethics of Genetic Engineering - The Philadelphia Citizen - November 20th, 2019
- Faith groups reckon with AI and what it means to be truly human - Worcester Telegram - November 20th, 2019
- Zoltan Istvan, a Leader in Science and Technology, Will Run for US President and Challenge Trump in the 2020 Republican Primaries - PR Web - November 20th, 2019
- The Most Elaborate Display of Ineptitude I Have Ever Witnessed: The BiChip Hoax - Patheos - November 20th, 2019
- What is biohacking? The new science of optimizing your brain and body. - Vox.com - November 20th, 2019
- Are LED lights and other techno-implants slowly turning us into the Borg? - SYFY WIRE - October 16th, 2019
- The transhumanists who are 'upgrading' their bodies - BBC News - October 8th, 2019
- Insight: Transhumanists believe in the bionic body beautiful - The Scotsman - October 8th, 2019
- Education and Enhancement in a Transhuman Future - Patheos - October 8th, 2019
- Heavy data protection regulation looms in Labour plans for post-Brexit flows and IoT devices - The Register - October 8th, 2019
- A Novel That Riffs on Sex Dolls, Mary Shelley and Brexit - The New York Times - October 8th, 2019
- Man meets machine: 21st century is age of the upgradeable human, says expert - Express.co.uk - October 8th, 2019
- Hereticon, From Peter Thiel's Founders Fund, Is a 'Conference for People Banned From Other Conferences' - The Daily Beast - October 8th, 2019
- Peter Thiel's Promised Land For Intellectual Troublemakers - SafeHaven.com - October 8th, 2019
- Automation and Utopia is Now Available! - Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies - September 28th, 2019
- Transhumanism as Simplified Humanism - Yudkowsky - May 1st, 2019
- Transhumanist politics - Wikipedia - May 1st, 2019
- Transhumanism | Future | FANDOM powered by Wikia - April 27th, 2019
- A New Generation of Transhumanists Is Emerging | HuffPost - April 20th, 2019
- Transhumanism - The Next Step to Super Humans? - April 12th, 2019
- U.S. Transhumanist Party PUTTING SCIENCE, HEALTH ... - March 4th, 2019
- Transhumanism in fiction - Wikipedia - February 9th, 2019
- Transhumanism - Work for human longevity - November 24th, 2018
- Transhuman | Future | FANDOM powered by Wikia - November 3rd, 2018
- Transhumanism: The Next Evolution of Man w. Zoltan Istvan (Video Interview) - September 29th, 2018
- The Ethics Of Transhumanism And The Cult Of Futurist Biotech - September 25th, 2018
- Transhumanism - September 9th, 2018
- Elevating the Human Condition - Humanity+ What does it mean ... - July 23rd, 2018
- Transhumanism - H+Pedia - hpluspedia.org - June 25th, 2018
- Posthuman - Wikipedia - June 17th, 2018
- The Responsibility of Immortality: Welcome to the New ... - June 9th, 2018
- Transhumanism - reddit - June 3rd, 2018
- Transhumanism Conference at Samford University - March 10th, 2018
- What is Transhumanism? - GenSix Productions - March 3rd, 2018
- Transhumanism - Ascension Glossary - February 26th, 2018
- Transhumanism | America Magazine - February 17th, 2018
- Transhumanism: A Final Corporate Takeover of Humanity - February 12th, 2018
- 'Altered Carbon' and TV's New Wave of Transhumanism | WIRED - February 10th, 2018
- 'The Red Strings Club' explores the morality of transhumanism - February 10th, 2018
- transhumanism Biblical Life Assembly - February 10th, 2018
- Transhumanism: The Anti-Human Singularity Agenda - November 26th, 2017
- What is transhumanism? | Christian Apologetics & Research ... - October 31st, 2017
- Transhumanism | Conspiracy School - October 31st, 2017
- No Transhumanism Allowed - TV Tropes - October 25th, 2017
- Hidden In Plain Sight - 4 Movies That Expose The Globalist ... - September 30th, 2017
- Transhumanism - Catholicism.org - September 6th, 2017