The Triumph of the Social Scientific Method | Carl R. Trueman – First Things
Posted: June 21, 2020 at 8:52 am
Nietzsche said that the nineteenth century was not distinguished by the victory of science but by the victory of the scientific method. His point was that once a claim could be dressed up as the result of a scientific procedure, it became culturally incontestable. Were Nietzsche writing today, he would need to modify the statement a little.
Take, for example, this intriguing 2016 article from Quartz, which was reposted last week. The writer, Thomas Page McBee, is a transgender person who claims to have experienced the workplace first as a woman and later, after transitioning, as a man. This modern-day Teiresias confirms what we have come to expectthat men are at a significant advantage in the workplace, at least according to the criteria she uses. More interesting than the predictable conclusions she draws, however, are the cultural pathologies she reflects.
The politics of contemporary social science now has an iron grip on what are deemed legitimate perceptions of reality. This is explicitly clear in what the article says and implicitly clear in what it doesn't say. The article presents the assumption that workplaces are best explicated by gender specialists as a simple matter of fact. And its lack of any reflection upon the Promethean philosophical presumptions of transgenderism indicates that the culture is at such a point on this issue that the writer feels absolutely no need to do so.
Whether McBee has reflected on the philosophical foundations that make transgenderism plausible is not clear, but her last two paragraphs are replete with what should be contentious metaphysical assumptions. Here she transitions from Teiresias to Aristophanes, proposing that there is a male and female version of ourselves inside each of usa tale worthy of an after-dinner speech at Agathons place. Then there is the fascinating comment in the final paragraph that most of us have the bodies we occupy because of luck of the draw. This is revealing because it makes clear that the distinction between sex and gender, now presented as an incontestable truth, rests upon an even more radical distinction: that between a persons identity and their body. What is fascinating is that none of this comes in the form of argument. It is presented as obvious, something only possible because of its conformity to the spirit of our age.
Yet there is no I behind or before the body. There is no us that exists (logically, let alone chronologically) independently of our flesh and that is then randomly assigned to the bodies we have. Our bodies are an integral part of who we are. And I do not occupy my body as I might occupy a house or a space suit or a deck chair at the beach. On the contrary, it is an integral part of me, inseparable from who I am. It is perhaps the foundational piece of evidence that, were I to claim that I am, for example, Attila the Hun or Nancy Pelosi, I would be talking nonsense, with my body as Exhibit A in the case for the prosecution. It is not simply instrumental to my identity; my identity is inseparable from it. To downgrade it to a mere incidental, or to set the real me in opposition to it, is a recipe for chaos. Even Christian theology, with its body-soul distinction, is clear on this: I am not my soul or my body. That is why Christianity teaches that we do not just leave our bodies and go to heaven. We are actually resurrected.
The articles implicit assumption, foundational to gender theory, is that gender is a performance, not a matter of biological sex, and therefore rooted in the ways in which power putatively works within any given society. Butto play the critical theorist cardgender is not the only category by which societies exert power and control. Age also plays such a role. And age, like gender, also has a culturally specific performative aspect as reflected in social practices, law codes, and cultural expectations.
To give a trivial example, I remember as a teenager lying about my age in order to see Monty Pythons The Meaning of Life at a local cinema. I was sixteen but pretended to be eighteen. I performed the role: I provided the wrong birthdate when asked, and generally tried to look as cool and confident as I thought eighteen-year-olds didand, amazing to tell, the girl at the ticket booth did not treat me as the sixteen-year-old I really was. She sold me a ticket and let me see the movie. The pretense made a difference and confirmed what I already knew: Adults are treated differently than children. But it did not make me eighteen. I was merely a sixteen-year-old pretending to be an adult. And even if I had been utterly convinced that I was eighteen and deeply hurt by anyone who said otherwise, I would still not have been eighteen.
What is striking about the transgender debate, therefore, is that something so counter-intuitive and rooted in such untenable philosophical positions is actually not a matter of debate at all at any significant level. Naysayers are simply dismissed as ignorant or bigots or both. The advent of the derogatory term TERF points to this, as does the social media fury that descends upon anyone who dares question the idea. The furor surrounding J. K. Rowling is just the latest example. And behind it all lie the highly contentious assumptions of gender theory marketed under the label of social science. But social science as it manifests itself in the work of Judith Butler and her progeny is really no more scientific than Marxs scientific socialism. And it serves the same purpose as it did for Marx: It creates an appearance of objectivity and thereby enables a highly contentious way of looking at the world to delegitimize any and all dissenting voices. It will not allow its hypotheses to be contestedindeed, even to think about contesting them is to show how benightedly reactionary one is. Yet make no mistake: It is merely ideology hiding itself under the fig leaf of scientific rhetoric.
In a 1979 article, Alasdair MacIntyre pointed out how social science methodology had become a fundamental tool of power in managerial bureaucracy. Forty years later, it is no longer merely managerial bureaucracy over which it holds sway. The cultural disenfranchising of anyone who wishes to question transgenderisms assumptions indicates that the same thing is now far advanced in society at large. To update Nietzsche, the twenty-first century looks set to witness not so much the triumph of social science as the triumph of the social scientific method.
Carl R. Truemanis professor of biblical and religious studies at Grove City College and senior fellow at the Institute for Faith and Freedom.His forthcoming book, The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self, is due to be published in November.
First Thingsdepends on its subscribers and supporters. Join the conversation and make a contribution today.
Clickhereto make a donation.
Clickhereto subscribe toFirst Things.
Read the original post:
The Triumph of the Social Scientific Method | Carl R. Trueman - First Things
- Arknights Lore: The Birth of Tragedy and Requiem - GamePress - January 9th, 2021
- Want to improve focus and productivity? Do one thing at a time - The Guardian - January 9th, 2021
- Theatre of the absurd - Economic Times - January 9th, 2021
- Darwinism as the Root Problem of Modernity - Discovery Institute - January 9th, 2021
- Past in Perspective - The Nation - January 9th, 2021
- Shaw, Scientism, and Darwinism - Discovery Institute - January 9th, 2021
- Asking Ourselves What is truth in a Post-COVID World? - The Nanjinger - December 21st, 2020
- In defence of egoism - TheArticle - December 21st, 2020
- The Telos Press Podcast: Robert Miner on the Division of Work and Play in Adorno's Minima Moralia - Telos Press - December 21st, 2020
- Assassin's Creed: after 13 years, 12 games and a ton of sales, what's the secret to the franchise's success? - The Conversation AU - December 21st, 2020
- Covid and the Winter of Our Discontent - AlleyWatch - December 21st, 2020
- The songs of David Bowie album Hunky Dory ranked in order of greatness - Far Out Magazine - December 21st, 2020
- Totally Not Fake News: The Latest Texans Fan - Battle Red Blog - December 3rd, 2020
- The Prom review is Ryan Murphy's musical the first film of the Biden era? - The Guardian - December 3rd, 2020
- Friedrich Nietzsche Birth Anniversary: Top 10 relatable love quotes by the philosopher - Newsd.in - October 16th, 2020
- Gazing into the abyss | Opinion | dchieftain.com - El Defensor Chieftain - October 16th, 2020
- Schadenfreude over Trumps COVID-19 diagnosis was more about cosmic justice than joy in anothers pain - Jacksonville Journal-Courier - October 16th, 2020
- 5-at-10 on fall break, Day 4: Fab 4 picks, Never picking against Saban, Braves are fine - Chattanooga Times Free Press - October 16th, 2020
- On Face Masks, God, Baseball, Kidneys and Cancer InsideSources - InsideSources - October 16th, 2020
- Artica makes its 'Eternal Return' October 10 and 11: 'Annual celebration of creativity, innovation, and exploration' on North Riverfront - St. Louis... - October 16th, 2020
- Behavioral Psychology and its Practical Implications - The Great Courses Daily News - October 16th, 2020
- Liberalism will remain vulnerable unless it can speak to our need for emotional storytelling - New Statesman - October 16th, 2020
- Lockdown read: The Unbearable Lightness of Being - The Mancunion - October 16th, 2020
- The Wild and the Disaffected: A Conversation with Reinaldo Iturriza (Part I) - Venezuelanalysis.com - October 16th, 2020
- Say yes to the world: On Nietzsche and affirmation - Big Think - September 12th, 2020
- Nietzsche and his wizards - The Rocky Mountain Goat - September 12th, 2020
- An augmented reality art exhibition will debut on the University of Chicago campus - Time Out Chicago - September 12th, 2020
- Ressentiment: He Hates, Therefore He Is | Chronicles - A Magazine of American Culture - September 12th, 2020
- Dangerous Intimacies: Racism, Risk, and Recovery - Psychotherapy.net - September 12th, 2020
- In Gratitude for the Executive Order on Critical Race Theory - Merion West - September 12th, 2020
- Wagnerism: Art and Politics in the Shadow of Music by Alex Ross review - The Guardian - September 12th, 2020
- Is 'cultural Marxism' really taking over universities? I crunched some numbers to find out - The Conversation AU - September 12th, 2020
- Lol nothing matters. Or does it? - The Week - September 12th, 2020
- Nietzsche's superman, Islam, and Covid-19 ( Part III) - Daily Times - August 22nd, 2020
- Nietzsche's superman, Islam, and Covid-19 ( Part I) - Daily Times - August 22nd, 2020
- Nietzsche's superman, Islam, and Covid-19 ( Part II) - Daily Times - August 22nd, 2020
- Leprosy of the soul? A brief history of boredom - The Conversation UK - August 22nd, 2020
- Free Will Astrology: August 19, 2020 - River Cities Reader - August 22nd, 2020
- Free Will AstrologyWeek of August 20 | Advice & Fun | Bend - The Source Weekly - August 22nd, 2020
- Don't misrepresent Atheism - The Shillong Times - August 22nd, 2020
- National Couple's Day 2020: Quotes About Love To Share With Your Partner - International Business Times - August 22nd, 2020
- Cold Chain Tracking And Monitoring Market 2020 | Coronavirus Impact Analysis | Trends, Innovation, Growth Opportunities, Demand, Application, Top... - August 22nd, 2020
- David Gilbert on John Hughes and Being Seventeen - The New Yorker - August 22nd, 2020
- On Faith: Individualism is America's religion | Perspective - Rutland Herald - August 22nd, 2020
- We are back in the culture wars, reversed - Las Cruces Sun-News - August 16th, 2020
- The Base: Exporting Accelerationist Terror - Southern Poverty Law Center - August 16th, 2020
- The Spiritual Work of a Worldly Life - Tricycle - August 16th, 2020
- Cold Chain Monitoring Market Research Report 2020 Covering Industry Size, Key Players Profiles, Trends and Forecast 2026 | Sensitech, Inc., NXP... - August 16th, 2020
- DODD COLUMN: Bubble gum came with laughs | Opinion - Evening News and Tribune - June 21st, 2020
- World Sauntering Day 2020: These 10 Quotes Will Remind You to Slow Down And Enjoy Life - India.com - June 21st, 2020
- Listen to them & understand them' - Ahmedabad Mirror - June 21st, 2020
- The new normal in education - The Jakarta Post - Jakarta Post - June 21st, 2020
- Telling the truth in a post-truth world - The Brussels Times - June 21st, 2020
- When Tribal Journalists Try to 'Cancel' Ayn Rand (Part 2) - New Ideal - June 21st, 2020
- Nihilism - Wikipedia - May 22nd, 2020
- Nietzsches Eternal Return | The New Yorker - May 22nd, 2020
- Best Friedrich Nietzsche Quotes | List of Famous Friedrich ... - May 22nd, 2020
- Graduation in the Times of COVID-19 | Schools Paid - Fallon County Extra - May 22nd, 2020
- Cold Chain Tracking and Monitoring Market Top Manufacturers, Consumption, Sales, Revenue & Trend For Next 5 Years - Cole of Duty - May 22nd, 2020
- These commencement speakers have wise words for these times - erienewsnow.com - May 22nd, 2020
- Gaze in Wonder at This Porsche 917/30 Flat-12 Fresh out of Canepas Shop - Autoweek - May 22nd, 2020
- Coronavirus: The Collapse of Higher Education -Or its Revolution? - Modern Diplomacy - May 22nd, 2020
- 'Outer Banks' co-creators talk Netflix, the UNC-Duke rivalry and the ferry to Chapel Hill - The Daily Tar Heel - May 22nd, 2020
- COVID-19 is a cruel reminder of the human condition - MinnPost - May 13th, 2020
- Your firm and the pandemic: Better after broken - Accounting Today - May 13th, 2020
- The Streets Ponders a Universal Question With New COVID-19 Track - Rolling Stone - May 10th, 2020
- Colby Cosh: Doing 'Houelle' in isolation France's sage transmits to the world - National Post - May 10th, 2020
- The one who integrates is lost - Daily Times - May 10th, 2020
- Global Temperature Data Logger Market Key Players, Application and Business Analysis over Distributed Regions Global Forecast to 2025. - Cole of Duty - May 10th, 2020
- Matters of laugh and death: Imagining 'The Good Place' [column] - LancasterOnline - May 4th, 2020
- Why Indians Need To Be More Rational Than Emotional When It Comes To Politics - Youth Ki Awaaz - May 4th, 2020
- Impact of Covid-19 on Cold Chain Tracking and Monitoring Systems Market Research Report 2020, Thrives the Global Industry Growth at Impressive CAGR... - May 4th, 2020
- Inside the Core this Week - Seton Hall University News & Events - April 30th, 2020
- The Mother Lode: Coronavirus carries unknowns, so does its recovery - CT Insider - April 30th, 2020
- The art of walking | Opinion - Murray Ledger and Times - April 3rd, 2020
- This is why youre bored in quarantine - TRT World - April 3rd, 2020
- Holocaust survivor's book applies in these times | Opinion - westvalleyview.com - April 3rd, 2020
- Cold Chain Tracking and Monitoring Devices Market Report by Manufacturers, Regions, Type and Application Forecast 2019 2025 - Science In Me - April 3rd, 2020
- Covid-19 life lessons from some of history's greatest thinkers - TheArticle - April 3rd, 2020
- Tech companies making the people dance to their tune in India - H2S Media - April 3rd, 2020