Is Jordan Peterson the New Ayn Rand? – Merion West
Posted: February 15, 2020 at 2:56 am
(Flickr-Gage Skidmore)
I compare Peterson with Ayn Rand becauseas I read this bookher name constantly came to my mind (she is mentioned only once in the book).
The Left has long had intellectual gurus with cult-like followings: from Derrida to Foucault to Sartre to iek. This is a less frequent occurrence on the Right, so there are fewer intellectual gurus to be found there. Perhaps the last such figure was Ayn Rand, and, even thoughshe has been dead for more than three decades, her views remain quite influential for some young people.So, the time is ripe for a new right-wing intellectual guru, and it seems Jordan Peterson is playing that role.
If you are a male college student, you might not mind watching Petersons long lectures on Solzhenitsynor reading his technical articles on the psychology of alcoholism. However, the rest of us would prefer to have a ready-made concise CliffNotes version of his ideas, chiefly to judge whether this Peterson fellow is actually worth all of the fuss that accompanies him. Jim Proser provides such a guide in Savage Messiah: How Dr. Jordan Peterson Is Saving Western Civilization. It is a nice intellectual biography, written in a very engaging style; it is never dumbed-down yet full of anecdotes. It also quotes extensively from Petersons own books, lectures, and interviews.
I compare Peterson with Ayn Rand becauseas I read this bookher name constantly came to my mind (she is mentioned only once in the book). In Atlas Shrugged, the boogeyman is socialism, and the dominant theme of that very long book is individuals rejecting herd-mentality and taking responsibility for their own actions; Atlas is the mythological hero, who embraces this ideal by taking the world on his shoulders. In Prosers portrayal, Peterson is similarly fascinated with Atlas, as this excerpt from one of his lectures demonstrates: This is an old representation, right? Atlas with the world. Well, its a representation that says that thats the proper way to live, right? [It] is to pick up a load thats heavy enough so that if you carry it you have some self-respect.
Points along these lines may sound more like self-help motivational coaching than insightful scholarship. And indeed, throughout Prosers book, one may sympathize with Peterson, but I still wonder what all the hand-wringing surrounding him is all about. Dont misunderstand me, Peterson is a legitimate scholar, but I can think of many, many contemporary intellectuals that have far more interesting things to say.
Now, maybe Petersons singularity is that he struck a chord in the right place at the right time. Political correctness and identity politics have gone too far, and free speech does appear to be under siege at many North American universities. As Proser tells the story, Peterson courageously has taken a stand against of all this. Kudos to him for that. However, I worry that there is something darker lurking underneath Petersons crusade.
Apart from Ayn Rand, the other author that constantly came to mind as I read the book was Nietzsche. Proser paints Peterson as some sort of bermensch, a figure who in his youth lifted weights, a roughneck, a frontier cowboy from the lonely Alberta oilfields he grew up fighting for his place in a wolf pack of tough guys. And, now, Peterson has become this savage intellectual, who exists beyond the mediocrity of the restand thrives by killing the dragons of chaos, fighting hard to reestablish order.
Now, of course, Nietzsche was not guilty of the way his philosophy was abused by the Nazis. But, I do give credence to the thesis that his ideas did sow the seeds of totalitarianism.If you worry so much about being a Superman, then ultimately it is not so hard to conclude that weaklings must simply disappear from the face of the Earth.Likewise, I worry thatunderneath all the talk about responsibility, order, and anti-political correctnessthere may be something more sinister going on with Peterson.
Proser presents Peterson as a champion of the Enlightenment, who prioritizes science over ideology, and calls a spade a spade by reminding liberals that gender differences are real. That may very well be, but I doubt Peterson is really committed to the Enlightenment and its true liberal spirit. Actually, I think Matt McManus hits it on the head when he claims that Peterson is much closer aligned with postmodernism and the counter-Enlightenment than he would be willing to admit. The Enlightenment turned its back on faith and Christianity as a whole; Peterson says he does not believe in God, but he, very confusingly, seems to think religion will always be necessaryand that atheism inevitably leads to many depravities. The Enlightenment was cosmopolitan and had little patience for nationalism; by contrast, the counter-Enlightenment provided the intellectual rationale for modern nationalism, and Peterson is similarlyunhappyabout what he calls globalism. The Enlightenment had little patience for pseudoscientific mumbo jumbo; by contrast, Peterson seems to think that people who painted snakes in antiquity already knew about DNA
But, perhaps the more worrying aspect of Peterson is his obsession with what he calls neo-Marxism and its alleged pernicious infiltration of our civilization. This is the dominant theme of Prosers book. Yes, there are some fools in North American universities, and Peterson does a public service by confronting them. But, to believe that these clueless college students are actually a threat to Western civilization (and that Peterson is a kind of Medieval knight who must slew the terrifying monsters) is hyperbole. If History is any guide, totalitarianism begins with hyperbole about the dangers of particular people, whether it is Jews, the bourgeoisie, or the Kafir. Of course, Communism killed millions of people, but to obsess over it may actually pave the way for new forms of totalitarianism. Those youngsters who are fascinated with Peterson should know that Stalinism and McCarthyism are cut from the same clothand, unfortunately, Petersons obsession with neo-Marxism (whatever that means) is dangerously close to the kind of intellectual cleansing that infamous Senator from Wisconsin senator aspired towards.
Precisely because Peterson has this illiberal bone, nasty people can become very fond of him. The Alt-right is a case in point. Of course, one ought never be charged with a crime on the basis of association (again, one cannot entirely blame Auschwitz on Nietzsche). But in the case of Peterson, it should at least give pause that his ideas are being used to push for someeyebrow-raising agendas. While he still has a chance to escape such guilt by associations, Peterson must try harder to disavow some of the tendentious readings that people make of his words.
Proser has written a nice book, but he also makes for an example of someone who wants to use Peterson for his own agenda of ultraconservatism and American triumphalism. Take, for instance, his views on American imperialism. In the book, there is constant mention of the Soviet Evil Empire but no mention whatsoever of any American Empire. Proser scolds Noam Chomsky for saying that, the United States also wiped out communist uprisings in Latin America with the methods of Heinrich Himmlers extermination squads. Well, like it or not, Chomsky is right this time. The United States illegal involvement in Nicaragua(and other countries south of Rio Grande) was intended to wipe out communist uprisings. Proserin dismissing offhandedly this comparisonignores that the School of the Americas run by the CIA taught Latin American dictatorships how to torture in order to suppress communist movements.
Proser is so far to the right, that he thinks that Obama was, the de facto leader of the left since his election in 2008. Proser even claims that, Jordan [Peterson] recognized the election of Barack Obama and explosion of Occupy Wall Street as clear demonstrations that a radical Marxist storm had surged and was aiming to collapse Western traditions as it had before. I do not know if Peterson actually thought this; however, if he did, then there is something wrong with him. To think that Barack Obama, who bailed out banks and Wall Street belongs in the same category with Occupy Wall Street is nothing more than unhealthy conspiratorial thinking.
One can easily guess Prosers political views by looking at which thinkers he invokes and approves of. When speaking of the Intellectual Dark Web, he mentions respectable names such as Sam Harris, Joe Rogan, and Ben Shapiro. But then, he includes Glenn Beck. Seriously? The same guy who rants about George Soros and toys with conspiracy theories over and over again? Someone who not only toys withbut rather fully embracesall sorts of conspiracy theories is Alex Jones. And Proser does seem to have a soft spot for him, too: Alex Jones would fall to de-platforming as social media monopolies Facebook, Google, and Twitter revealed themselves to be in the progressive camp by using the new standard hate speech is not free speech to throttle conservative, or as Jordan [Peterson] described himself, traditionalist voices.
It is nice to have someone to give young adults advice about discipline, order, and responsibility. It is also nice to have a professor on television telling woke crusaders that the State has no right to force people to use specific pronounsand that not everything is about race. But, if by talking so much about the Gulag, you forget about Guantanamo, we have a problem. No, I do not claim moral equivalency; the Gulag was certainly worse. But, I cannot emphasize enough that obsession with Stalinism can lead to McCarthyismor the Patriot Actand Peterson needs to think harder about how to prevent this.
He still has time to avoid going down the path of Ayn Rand. In her case, one can understand how closely witnessing the horrors of the Russian Revolution led to her extremist views. By contrast, Peterson has had the privilege of living in democratic nations his entire life. Sure, he has reason to strongly object to Communism, but his own unchecked views may be promoting a world that few sensible people would want. I worry thatin the endthis famous quotation by John Rogers may also apply to Petersons work: There are two novels that can change a bookish fourteen-year olds life:The Lord of the RingsandAtlas Shrugged.One is a childish fantasy that often engenders a lifelong obsession with its unbelievable heroes, leading to an emotionally stunted, socially crippled adulthood, unable to deal with the real world. The other, of course, involves orcs.
Dr. Gabriel Andrade is a university professor. He has previously contributed to Areo Magazine and DePauw Universitys The Prindle Post. His twitter is@gandrade80
View post:
Is Jordan Peterson the New Ayn Rand? - Merion West
- You Can't Beat COVID-19 With Diet, No Matter What the Internet Tells You - Lifehacker - December 17th, 2020
- MSU students and professor publish research internationally - Morehead State University News - December 17th, 2020
- Freedom of speech at universities is not under threat it is actually thriving - The Independent - December 17th, 2020
- Michael Eric Dyson on how not to waste this moment of racial awakening - The Philadelphia Citizen - December 17th, 2020
- Sator Trailer Reveals a Deeply Horrifying Hybrid of Fiction and Fact - Collider - December 17th, 2020
- Notebook: Miles says 'practice and competition' will determine whether Kendrick starts again - KUsports - December 14th, 2020
- Three Positive and Negative Takeaways from Cardinals Win Over Giants - Sports Illustrated - December 14th, 2020
- All Love in Lindale: Eagles headed to first state championship game with game-winning field goal - Tyler Morning Telegraph - December 14th, 2020
- The Real Appeal of Jordan Peterson - Merion West - December 11th, 2020
- Why Jordan Peterson's Message on Gratitude Is More Important Than Ever | Jon Miltimore - Foundation for Economic Education - December 11th, 2020
- A round with Patrick Peterson: Golf with Michael Jordan, Passionfruit Truly and an idea for The Match - usatoday.com - December 11th, 2020
- Letters to the editor: 'Let's see some realism about Canada's place in the world' - National Post - December 11th, 2020
- New political science book shows how American exceptionalism is fading and what to do about it - Yahoo Finance - December 11th, 2020
- Prep roundup: Columbus goes 2-1 on the mat - Waterloo Cedar Falls Courier - December 11th, 2020
- Jordan Peterson and the Return of Solzhenitsyn - Merion West - November 2nd, 2020
- Kindred: Bob Loys legacy? His lifes work will live on - The Pantagraph - November 2nd, 2020
- The numbers that prove Meteorettes are something special - Daily Mercury - November 2nd, 2020
- Property transfers | News, Sports, Jobs - The Review - November 2nd, 2020
- Revision 8.2 A further note on the rededication of Palestine - Patheos - November 2nd, 2020
- Gameday inactives, injuries and weather: Week 8 - The Huddle - November 2nd, 2020
- NFL trade rumors: 15 players most likely to be traded at the 2020 deadline - Sporting News - November 2nd, 2020
- Week 8 Fantasy Football Booms and Busts: Should we be worried about Lamar, Big Ben? - Yahoo Sports - November 2nd, 2020
- American Health Will Sink the GOP in November - TheStranger.com - October 4th, 2020
- Lions OC Darrell Bevell: Kerryon Johnson was the player of the game - MLive.com - October 4th, 2020
- Panthers top Cardinals in 31-21 win - Greensboro News & Record - October 4th, 2020
- The Crowding out of a Humanities Education - Merion West - October 4th, 2020
- Joe Rogans Spotify Debut Sparks Speculation Over Missing Episodes - Forbes - September 7th, 2020
- Russell Howard: 'The real world isnt social media' - The Guardian - September 7th, 2020
- Should the Kansas City Chiefs consider signing Adrian Peterson? - Arrowhead Addict - September 7th, 2020
- 2020 NFL roster cuts tracker: See every cut from all 32 teams after initial rosters trimmed to 53 players - CBS Sports - September 7th, 2020
- Leonard Fournette landing spots: Patriots, Buccaneers lead the top five - CBS Sports - September 7th, 2020
- Jordan Peterson saw this coming a while ago - Sarnia Observer - August 28th, 2020
- The RNC is turning into one long right-wing Youtube video - Business Insider - Business Insider - August 28th, 2020
- Camden couple involved in fake will scheme released from federal prison - El Dorado News-Times - June 16th, 2020
- Five defensive players the Arizona Cardinals need to live up to expectations in 2020 - Revenge of the Birds - June 16th, 2020
- Dave Rubin On Where Liberals And Conservatives Can Agree, And Can't - The Federalist - June 16th, 2020
- YouTube sells subscriptions with just one word heres how you can emulate it - The Next Web - June 4th, 2020
- Avoid This #1 Mistake and You Will Be Rich - Stock Investor - June 4th, 2020
- On the Limits of Dave Rubins Cultural Politics - National Review - June 4th, 2020
- Patrick Peterson sees 'championship-caliber team from top to bottom' in Cardinals - Cards Wire - June 4th, 2020
- Lower Dauphin High School releases final honor rolls of school year - Middletown Press and Journal - June 4th, 2020
- University of Alberta fires anthropology professor for saying biological sex is real - The Post Millennial - June 4th, 2020
- Howard Balzer on Cardinals Tempering Expectations - Sports Illustrated - June 4th, 2020
- Kuiper: Stop playing the victim | Opinion | nwestiowa.com - nwestiowa.com - May 25th, 2020
- Jonathan Kay: It takes a true artist to find new ways to shock the conscience. Kent Monkman has done that - National Post - May 25th, 2020
- Graduation 2020: Westby Area High School - The Westby Times - May 25th, 2020
- Cardinals reportedly have interest in Everson Griffen - NBCSports.com - May 25th, 2020
- Jordan Peterson is back at work on his next book - May 20th, 2020
- The one ACC team Michael Jordan wanted to beat most while at North Carolina - Sporting News - May 20th, 2020
- Michael Jordan wanted to beat one ACC team more than any other - 247Sports - May 20th, 2020
- Patrick Peterson: This is probably best team Ive been part of on paper - Yahoo Sports - May 20th, 2020
- The Indy Book Club: Convenience Store Woman is a gothic love story with a sickly capitalist kink - The Independent - May 20th, 2020
- Wisconsin Bars Flooded With Traffic, Or Are They? - TheStreet - May 20th, 2020
- What Happened to Jordan Peterson? | The New Republic - May 13th, 2020
- Jordan B. Peterson Health Update: Author Is Recovering ... - May 13th, 2020
- Jordan Peterson recovering from tranquilizer addiction - May 13th, 2020
- Imperium Group Features Top Disruptors and Entrepreneurs of 2020 - GlobeNewswire - May 13th, 2020
- RED DENNIS & The Politics of Disrespect - The Milpitas Beat - May 13th, 2020
- 'Cuck Zone' Artist Is Happy That Twitter Thinks Her Work Is 'Rad' - Newsweek - May 13th, 2020
- Mohamed and the Mountain | Annette Poizner | The Blogs - The Times of Israel - May 13th, 2020
- Bob Holliday talks about the fun day when MJ and Buzz Peterson went golfing - WRALSportsFan.com - May 13th, 2020
- An autopsy of the Intellectual Dark Web - The Spectator USA - May 13th, 2020
- Dave Rubin interview: His new book, censorship on the left and what he sees happening in Canada - National Post - May 13th, 2020
- All Our 2019 Corrections And Clarifications - CANADALAND - May 13th, 2020
- Jordan Peterson and Carl Jung's Worldviews Have Been Greatly Oversimplified - Merion West - April 30th, 2020
- Dave Rubin Talks To Shapiro About Learning From Jordan Peterson On Tour - The Daily Wire - April 30th, 2020
- The one player Michael Jordan was scared of in college? Buzz Peterson details it - The Athletic - April 30th, 2020
- Michael Jordan feared a certain NFL legend on the basketball court, according to his North Carolina roommate - CBS Sports - April 30th, 2020
- Michael Jordan's 'last dance' at Carolina, through the eyes of his teammates - Winston-Salem Journal - April 30th, 2020
- The Problem with Edmund Burke and Defenders of Tradition - Merion West - April 30th, 2020
- Russell Brand And Ricky Gervais Are Just What Your Brain Needs - The Federalist - April 30th, 2020
- Justin Rohrwasser Has Right-Wing Paramilitary Gang Tattoo - The Root - April 30th, 2020
- FreedomFest Urges People to 'Catch the Vision' in Las Vegas - Right Wing Watch - April 30th, 2020
- There Was Only One Player Michael Jordan Feared Playing, According To Former Teammate At UNC - BroBible - April 30th, 2020
- A short stretch in the cult of yoga - The Conservative Woman - April 30th, 2020
- Bird Droppings: Arizona Cardinals preparing for virtual draft, Jordan Phillips looks to build on career year - Revenge of the Birds - April 12th, 2020
- Announcing the Release of Myth and Mayhem: A Leftist Critique of Jordan Peterson - Merion West - March 7th, 2020
- Has teaching objective truths become inconvenient? - University World News - March 7th, 2020
- The best recent poetry review roundup - The Guardian - March 7th, 2020
- Big 12 Offseason Tracker: Kansas States Joe Klanderman promoted to DC - Burnt Orange Nation - March 7th, 2020