Graduates of Elite Universities Get Paid More. Do They Perform Better? – Harvard Business Review
Posted: September 8, 2020 at 8:00 am
A busy HR manager is reviewing stacks of applications for a position that just opened in the company. The HR manager knows that a host of factors determine employee performance: prior experience, training, interpersonal skills, personality, IQ, emotional intelligence, and work ethic. But after reviewing hundreds of resumes, as many HR managers do, the details on each applicant blur together. And so the HR manager does what many employers do: defaults to selecting hires based on the prestige and rank of the university from which graduates hail.
Presumably, better universities attract better students and provide better training, so it makes sense to use the university rank as a predictor of employee performance. This, after all, is why employers offer higher starting salaries to hires selected from prestigious schools. But is it a good hiring strategy? Do university rankings predict job performance? Our research suggests yes but only to a degree.
Why top-tiered college graduates perform (nominally) better than their peers
In a recent study, we tested the relationship between the university rank and performance of graduates. We tracked the performance of 28,339 students from 294 universities in 79 countries. The students came from 294 universities that ranked from Top 10 to about top 20,000 in the Webometrics global university rankings that rank over 30,000 universities worldwide. We observed the students performance for two months as they were working in global virtual teams on real-life business consulting projects for a number of corporate clients. Importantly, we captured not only the quality of the output, but a wide range of hard and soft competencies including cooperation with team members, leadership, language proficiency, technical skills, emotional intelligence, creativity, and more.
Our results offer some solace to the traditional recruiters. After controlling for age, gender, and the year of study, we found that graduates from higher-ranked universities performed better, but only nominally and only on some dimensions of performance. Specifically, the overall performance improved by only 1.9% for every 1,000 positions in the Webometrics global university rankings. When comparing the performance of candidates whose universities rank further apart a graduate from a top university versus a global average university the performance differential jumps to 19%.
The 19% difference in performance between the top and the average seems significant, but keep in mind that this is for graduates from universities that are 10,000 university ranking positions apart. At a given organization, candidates are likely to be selected from within a much narrower pool, perhaps from universities whose rankings differ by a couple of hundred positions. In this more realistic case, the predicted difference in performance would be closer to 1%.
We found several reasons why the graduates from the top universities performed somewhat better than those from the lower-ranked schools. The first was selection: higher-ranked universities usually can choose from a larger pool of applicants, which leads to steeper competition and a higher quality of the incoming class. Corroborating the selectivity hypothesis, our data demonstrated that students at higher-ranked universities indeed score higher on general cognitive ability tests, have more international experience, better English proficiency, and higher cultural intelligence. However, competitive selection suggests that these competencies may have been attained earlier in their education and, thus, is not a result of their university studies.
Second, higher-ranked universities should provide better training. Top universities employ better instructors, offer access to better-equipped facilities, attract better speakers and guests to campus, which in turn, should lead to better training and subsequent performance. Indeed, our data suggest that students at higher-ranked universities score higher on competencies that could be attributed to better training, such as superior technical and business writing skills, are more knowledgeable in subjects related to the business project, and score higher on team leadership and coordination.
Finally, while it might be expected that higher-ranked institutions might provide a more stimulating academic environment, we did not document that this had an effect on graduates work performance. Indeed, education is not only lectures and seminars. Having notable, hardworking, celebrity-status professors, along with being around intelligent, highly-motivated, achievement-oriented peers, positively affects self-efficacy, motivation, effort, and work ethic. However, our study revealed no difference in these performance-related attributes. Based on our data, the institutional environment did not seem to play a role in enhancing performance. Graduates from lower-ranked universities showed an equal level of motivation and work ethics, so this could be more affected by personality and other individual factors.
The downsides of superior academic pedigree
Despite their slightly better overall performance, hiring graduates from higher-ranked institutions could have a downside. Our data suggest that students from higher-ranked universities might damage team dynamics, sometimes inadvertently. We found that graduates from higher-ranked universities tend to excessively focus on the instrumental tasks, often at the expense of paying insufficient attention to interpersonal relationships. In some instances, graduates from top universities tend to be less friendly, are more prone to conflict, and are less likely to identify with their team.
Numerous studies have shown that interpersonal relationships at work play a critical role in employee motivation, job satisfaction, and, ultimately, performance and career success. As good interpersonal relationships are critical for organizational success, lacking collegiality and a propensity towards conflict could present adverse effects not only on personal performance, but also team and workgroup efficacy, possibly leading to an overall net loss.
Notably, graduates from high-ranking universities tend to share a common identity and could see themselves as different from their team members from a lower-ranking university, and this social categorization can lead to us-vs.-them dynamics. As a result, graduates from top universities could be perceived by their co-workers with less impressive academic pedigrees as arrogant and snobby, and because of that not liked by their peers. Our data did not confirm that this was the case. In fact, students from more prestigious universities tended to be more modest in their self-evaluations than some of their peers from lower-ranked institutions. However, we found that while students from higher-ranked universities generated more conflict, engaged in fewer non-instrumental conversations, and displayed less team commitment and identification with their teams.
So, whom should you hire?
While job candidates from more prestigious universities may slightly outperform their peers, data from Payscale and the U.S Department of Education show that these graduates are also more expensive to hire. For example, the average early career salaries of graduates from the top 10 colleges ($72,160) in the United States are 47% higher than those with degrees from the ten colleges within the City University New York (CUNY) school system ($48,960), many of which are ranked within the top 100. At the 6-year mark, that gap jumps to 108 percent.
Is the extra cost worth the investment? To answer this question, employers need to carefully consider the worth of the increase in performance for the firm. For some companies, the difference between a hypothetical graduate from an average vs. top university may be well worth the extra pay. Yet, for others, the added cost may not result in a positive return on investment and, thus, may not be justified. All in all, our results suggest that hiring graduates from higher-ranked universities would lead to a nominal improvement in performance. However, the university rank alone is a poor predictor of individual job performance. Employers can get a much better deal by hiring the right students from lower-ranked institutions, than anyone from better-ranked institutions. It would also be wise to use additional tests designed to evaluate the technical and interpersonal competencies needed for the job.
Considering the growing gap between skills acquired in college versus on-the-job readiness, any modest performance advantage stemming from the university rank might also be mitigated by on-the-job training. Since employers already invest significant resources into training new hires, such training may be a much better determinant of performance than the rank of the university from which the hire hails.
To a large extent, the answer would also depend on specific job demands. Does the job require a top performer from a higher-ranked university where even a 2% improvement in performance is critically important and offsets any pay differential? Or can the performance criteria be met by graduates from lesser-ranked universities? To make the most strategic decision, an HR manager should know the answer to this question before they look at an applicants college pedigree.
Contributors to this article include:Alexander Assouad, assistant professor of IB and Strategy at Belmont University; Alfredo Jimenez, associate professor at KEDGE Business School; Justin Kraemer, lecturer at Mae Fah Luang University; Anna Svirina, Dean of Engineering Economics and Entrepreneurship School at the Kazan National Research Technical University; Weng Si (Clara) Lei, program coordinator of Tourism Event Management and Assistant Professor at the Macao Institute for Tourism Studies.
Read the original post:
Graduates of Elite Universities Get Paid More. Do They Perform Better? - Harvard Business Review
- $10,000 Invested in This ETF Could Send Your Kids to College - Tulsa World - December 26th, 2020
- It's Time to Rethink Employee Performance Management - GovExec.com - December 26th, 2020
- New Years Eve Will Still Rock In Times Square, Even Without A Live Audience - Deadline - December 26th, 2020
- With his sudden U-turn over Christmas, Boris Johnson caps a year of debacles - The Guardian - December 26th, 2020
- Best gas grills of 2021: Weber, Char-Broil and more - CNET - December 26th, 2020
- Perigee Raises Pre-Seed to Bring Security and Performance to HVAC and Environmental Controls - PRNewswire - December 19th, 2020
- Apple M1 tested: Performance benchmarks and thermal throttling - Android Authority - December 19th, 2020
- Chadwick Boseman should win the Oscar for this scene in Netflix's 'Ma Rainey's Black Bottom' - Fast Company - December 19th, 2020
- Personal loan: Small-ticket disbursements up five times in 2 years - Moneycontrol.com - December 19th, 2020
- Microsoft Is Working On Arm-Based Chips For Azure, Surface PCs: Report - CRN - December 19th, 2020
- Sony X900H 4K LED TV Review: sleek design and a great picture - Reviewed - December 19th, 2020
- Calphalon Cool Touch Convection Toaster Oven is just $210, almost its all-time low price - CNET - December 19th, 2020
- Stocks making the biggest moves midday: Tesla, FedEx, Airbnb, Winnebago & more - CNBC - December 19th, 2020
- These are 20 of the 18,000 people who died of COVID-19 in the US this week - Business Insider - Business Insider - December 19th, 2020
- COVID-19 vaccine is flying high and on dry ice to reach you - CNET - December 19th, 2020
- The carrier battle over 5G will only escalate in 2021 - CNET - December 19th, 2020
- From turboprops to third force: Rexs bold move to shake up Australian aviation - Sydney Morning Herald - December 19th, 2020
- The MSI Prestige 14 Evo Review: Testing The Waters Of Tiger Lake - AnandTech - December 19th, 2020
- Australia vs India: Don`t have any personal goals, says the talented Shubman Gill - Zee News - November 24th, 2020
- The Personal History Of David Copperfield Review: Dev Patels Performance As The Title Character Of Dickens' Classic Is Very Enthusiastic - SpotboyE - November 24th, 2020
- How to choose the right hybrid fund based on your investment horizon - Moneycontrol.com - November 24th, 2020
- Astronauts on a Mars mission will need to be 'conscientious' to work well together - CNN - November 24th, 2020
- WISeKey's Cybersecurity AI technology creates a platform that helps connected devices to become intelligent devices, organize themselves into trusted... - November 24th, 2020
- 4 Reasons You Can't Afford to Invest Like the Wealthy - Mooresville Tribune - September 21st, 2020
- University Theatre to open season with virtual performance of Glass Menagerie - Mahoning Matters - September 21st, 2020
- Here's Why Municipal Bonds Belong in Every Investor's Portfolio - Mooresville Tribune - September 21st, 2020
- Johnson back to No. 1 with performance that looked the part - Chattanooga Times Free Press - August 25th, 2020
- Mill Creek mayor resigns mid-term, citing personal reasons - The Daily Herald - August 25th, 2020
- Global Silicone For Personal Care Market 2020 Industry Outlook Dow Corning Corporation, Momentive Performance Materials, BASF SE - Scientect - August 25th, 2020
- Personal Mobility Devices Market is Booming Worldwide 2020-2027 | NOVA Medical Products, Performance Health, Drive DeVilbiss Healthcare, Medline... - August 25th, 2020
- RNC 2020: Republicans open convention with rising stars, dark warnings - AL.com - August 25th, 2020
- Personal Protective Textile Market (Impact of COVID-19) Top Growing Companies: Royal Ten Cate NV,DuPont,WL Gore and Associates,Kusumgar... - July 5th, 2020
- Kalamazoo Growlers win on opening day in front of 100 fans happy to see baseball - MLive.com - July 3rd, 2020
- Failed by the system? Asylum seekers wait to call Scotland home - STV Edinburgh - July 3rd, 2020
- J&J Healthy Workforce Program: Bringing Purpose and Productivity to Life - OrthoSpineNews - June 12th, 2020
- Global Personal Care Polymer Ingredients Market 2020 Key Performance, Top Players, Segmentation, Future Plans and Forecast to 2025 - Cole of Duty - June 12th, 2020
- Andrew Peller Limited Reports Solid Operating Performance in Fiscal 2020 - GlobeNewswire - June 12th, 2020
- BTS Take Over Dear Class Of 2020 With 3-Song Performance And Personal Sentiments From Each Member - ETCanada.com - June 12th, 2020
- Global Enterprise Performance Management Market Expanding Rapidly with Forecast 2025 and Top Players : Adaptive Insights, Anaplan, BOARD... - June 12th, 2020
- How Coronavirus is Impacting Specialty and High Performance Films (Polyester, Nylon, Fluoropolymer, Polycarbonate and Others) Market Reflecting a CAGR... - June 12th, 2020
- COVID-19 impact: Insight on the Growth of Performance Coating Market Growth with Challenges, Standardization, Competitive Market Share and Top Players... - June 12th, 2020
- How Diverse Is Your Board, Really? - Harvard Business Review - June 12th, 2020
- Global Employee Performance Software Market 2020: Classification, Application And Specifications, Industry Overview, Analysis Of The Main Key Regions... - June 12th, 2020
- Potential impact of coronavirus outbreak on High-Performance Nonwovens Market 2020: Global Industry Analysis, Size, Share, Trends, Growth and Forecast... - June 12th, 2020
- Server Spending Measures Aspiration As Much As Oomph - The Next Platform - June 12th, 2020
- How BTS Became The Undisputed Kings Of K-Pop - British Vogue - June 12th, 2020
- Report finds massive drop in Canadians' willingness to disclose personal information for free online services - GlobeNewswire - May 28th, 2020
- CFOs of FUGAZ and their 3-year performance record - Nairametrics - May 28th, 2020
- Calls to ramp up scrutiny of teacher performance - Sydney Morning Herald - May 28th, 2020
- Valorant Ranked System Explained: How Competitive Ranks And Tiers Work - GameSpot - May 28th, 2020
- Avoid investing in different funds of a single AMC as they perform in unison - Livemint - May 28th, 2020
- Best Chase Business Credit Cards of 2020 Forbes Advisor - Forbes - May 28th, 2020
- The scores are in: America failed the virus test | Moran - NJ.com - May 28th, 2020
- Letter to The Editor: Reopening restaurants with digital handwashing - Food Safety News - May 10th, 2020
- Trump's incompetence makes Andrew Cuomo's performance look better than it is - CNN - May 10th, 2020
- Taylor Swift's Sang "Soon You'll Get Better" Live For the First Time in an Emotional Performance - POPSUGAR - April 21st, 2020
- While the NBA season is on hold, this Bucks' Rim Rocker continues shooting trick shots from his Oak Creek home - Milwaukee Journal Sentinel - April 21st, 2020
- Haley Downey Named Big 12 Women's Swimming & Diving Co-Scholar Athlete of the Year - Kansas Jayhawks - April 21st, 2020
- Performance Management: The Emphasis on Accountability - GovExec.com - February 22nd, 2020
- Denison women compete at Kenyon Fast Chance Invite - Big Red Athletics - February 22nd, 2020
- Warren Leads an Onslaught of Attacks, Zeroing In on Bloomberg - The New York Times - February 22nd, 2020
- HPR: Deadly tomatoes led former executive to riveting solo performance - Calgary Herald - January 9th, 2020
- What Russell Wilson Eats in a Day Is Nearly Impossible for 'Regular People' - Sportscasting - January 9th, 2020
- Golden Globes: who will win and who should win the film awards? - The Guardian - January 9th, 2020
- Uiagalelei arrives on campus after solid performance in All-American Game - Clemson Sports Talk - January 9th, 2020
- Satire, podcasts and an Olympian: High Performance Rodeo brings the 'wild' to Calgary - CBC.ca - January 9th, 2020
- The Bafta 2020 nominations prove the industry treats diversity as a fad - British GQ - January 9th, 2020
- Don't fall prey to the stock market's banner year - CNBC - January 3rd, 2020
- 'Work has fully invaded our personal lives.' Here are 8 ways we can work smarter in 2020 - NBC News - January 3rd, 2020
- Reframing resolutions - The Baxter Bulletin - January 3rd, 2020
- Current Recovery & Performance Thursday Wrestling Scoreboard, 1/2/20 - shoresportsnetwork.com - January 3rd, 2020
- Spectacular multidisciplinary performance journeys through 5000 years of civilization - Seattle Weekly - January 3rd, 2020
- Business-aligned learning: the role of L&D - TrainingZone.co.uk - January 3rd, 2020
- Delta Air Lines is the most on-time airline in North America - The Points Guy - January 3rd, 2020
- Burrow Backs Up Heisman Trophy w/Record-Breaking Performance - WTMM 104.5 The Team - ESPN Radio - January 3rd, 2020
- Briefly speaking - University of Dayton - News Home - January 3rd, 2020
- 2020 NFL Playoff Bracket Projection: Chiefs get Andy Reid first Super Bowl win over Saints - CBS Sports - January 3rd, 2020
- 50 Best Country Songs of the 2010s - Taste of Country - January 3rd, 2020
- Howard powers hot-shooting offense past brother's alma mater - Marquette Wire - December 29th, 2019
- Amy Winehouses Personal Property to Be Auctioned - Barron's - December 29th, 2019