Zen, Yoga, Gurdjieff- perspectives on inner work
Posted: June 26, 2018 at 3:44 pm
The Christian masters of the Middle Ages understood this matter better, perhaps, than anyone since in the western world. Speaking in a language we no longer fully (or in many cases even partially) understand, they described the necessary state as an awareness of sin.
This word used to mean something quite different than it does today and, once again, one could write an entire book about it. (The word is not derived from action or attachment in the outer world but applies in its esoteric sense exclusively to inner contradictions.) Gurdjieff, through his understanding of remorse of conscience and intentional suffering, more properly represents the question in front of us than any philosophy, whether theoretical or practical, of obliteration. Viewed from this perspective, liberation philosophies and doctrines of obliteration of Self are a cop-out.
A decent analogy of mankinds position in regard to the question of bliss is one of a parent owning a candy store. With the trusting parent in absentia, the child is left in charge of the sweets; but instead of respectfully guarding the wares, he or she begins to eat the sweets, not realizing that as tantalizing as they are, they are not meant for them.
There are fairy tales about such things, such as Hansel and Gretel and the gingerbread house. In that case we see that Hansel and Gretel very nearly become food for the house of bliss, rather than the other way around. It is their very unawareness, their naivet itself (the obliteration), that presents the danger. Lost and unconscious, they stumble across inner treasures; not knowing their right place or value, they enter the house (fully identify with its nature.) Tellingly, in this case, the ginger in the house is a spice from the east. The fairy tale may thusat its root, pun intended represent an esoteric warning against various naive forms of eastern liberation philosophy.
We can see the inherent danger in adopting philosophies or practices of oblivion; the annihilation (the making-into-nothingness) of the ego is not an answer. The ego exists to offer the opportunity to suffer it; extinguishment removes the source of conflict from which true suffering arises. Again, the metaphysical laws and reasonings behind this are complex; but the fact itself is rather simple. One doesnt need to know how all the gears work to know that the hands of the clock show us the time.
This leads me to the second question on the table in my discourse, which is the value of wordlessness. It follows on the philosophy of obliteration, since obliteration dovetails quite neatly into the evaporation of awareness, rationality, and everything they representincluding the words to describe them.
Its quite true that there is a place beyond words available to consciousness. As I have pointed out many times before, however, it is not just the metaphysically endowed (higher) states of awareness without words which we seek to encounter. There are awarenesses without words right next to us, so proximate in consciousness that we routinely take them for granted and ignore them; and these are the places (minds) without words that actually matter in the cultivation of our inner metaphysics, in the balancing of the centers Gurdjieff described as necessary in order to usefully receive higher states.
These two wordless minds are the intelligence of the body (sensation) and the intelligence of emotion (feeling.) Both are fully functioning fractions of our summary intelligence, ignored and suborned by the intellect in its prosecution of our rational (i.e., calculated) agendas. Yet these two wordless intelligences lie within our purview, not in some imaginary realm of better purity.
I would like you, for a moment, to imagine an idealized world without words in which all of the denizens never speak a single word to one another. I think we can agree that this world describes the world not of mankind, but of animals; and even they have languages, so perhaps we do not reach low enough down the scale when we say that. The point, i think, is that everything that human beings are, enlightened or otherwise, depends on the language we so eagerly banish when we try to speak about higher states of Being.
Without languagewithout words there is no art, no culture, no architecture, tradition, science, or society. Humanity as we know it ceases to exista welcome development, perhaps, for the proponents of oblivion, but clearly insufficient as either a condition, cause or objective of human existence. So these philosophies of oblivion, experiential or otherwise, are essentially inhuman.
They contradict the tradition of God as a person, of mankind as a microcosmic expression of God, and the entire nature of existence itself as it manifests in the juxtaposition of God and man. They are, in other words, so apophatic that they do away not only with the signs of man and God, but with man and God itself. The idea, once examined with intensity, is so profoundly and essentially stupid it would not be worth examining, but for the blithely unexamined Very Important Sounding things said in its name.
We are thinking creatures; it is part of our nature, and we deny it at our peril. God is, as well, a thinking nature-above-creation, a pre-existing thought before thinking. Our spiritual development does not, in other words, excuse us from thinking in an invitation to infinite realms of divine and nihilistic thoughtlessness; it requires an intensification of attention and thought, which is precisely what Gurdjieff brought, over and over again, to his pupilsand in his metaphysics and mythology. There are no realms of inattentive bliss mapped out in Beelzebubs cosmos; even purgatory (which would seem to be the most likely candidate) is a place of contemplation intensified to the level of the intolerable. Gurdjieffs famous aphorism, If you have not by nature a critical mind your staying here is useless, sums it all up; but all his aphorisms are directed at an intensification of intelligence that requires words.
Pretending that we can do without them is a form of rank sophistry; and yet one hears such talk quite often.
Yes; there are wordless places; yes, perhaps from time to time we touch them (or, more properly, they touch us.) Yet this is of no use in the enterprise of relationship, which demands that we do much more than just senseor just feelor just think. There is thought without thought; there is thought within thought; and there are parts that think without words, yet express in their own language nonetheless.
We should stop acting surprised about this. It is not the territory we stake out; it is the life we inhabit.
Let us stop speaking about the silence. Let us speak as we speak; and be silent as we may be silent; but in either case, let us be as we be, not as declarative shades of oblivion or wordlessness would have us be.Hosanna.
See the original post here:
Zen, Yoga, Gurdjieff- perspectives on inner work
- The clothing visionary who refuses to buy fashion magazines - Sydney Morning Herald - August 14th, 2020
- Full Album Stream: In the Company of Serpents - "Lux" - decibelmagazine.com - May 16th, 2020
- Jean Toomers Odd, Keening A Drama of the Southwest - The New Yorker - March 23rd, 2020
- Interview with Luis Amman, author of the book "Self- Liberation - Pressenza, International Press Agency - March 16th, 2020
- Arts, culture, fun in London this weekend and beyond (March 12-18) - The London Free Press - March 16th, 2020
- Learn to spin a hula hoop or jam with fellow musicians at these sessions in Bengaluru - Bangalore Mirror - December 18th, 2019
- From Brixton to Japan and back: Zelda Rhiando and the Brixton Bookjam - BrixtonBuzz - December 1st, 2019
- The Mystic and the Priest: The Gurdjieff Ensemble Performs Komitas - Armenian Weekly - September 19th, 2019
- For Peter Brook, the Experimental Showman, Nothing Is Ever Finished - The New York Times - September 19th, 2019
- New to this Work? Start Here - George Gurdjieff | Be Community - July 31st, 2019
- Quest The Gurdjieff Society - May 25th, 2019
- Gurdjieff's Teaching of The Fourth Way is The Original Teaching - May 12th, 2019
- archives.nypl.org -- Howarth Gurdjieff Archive - May 5th, 2019
- Gurdjieff Foundation of Louisiana home - April 28th, 2019
- George Gurdjieff | OSHO Transform Yourself through the ... - April 18th, 2019
- The Enneagram - Gurdjieff Legacy - April 7th, 2019
- Fourth Way | George Gurdjieff | Be Community - December 23rd, 2018
- Gurdjieff and Hypnosis: A Hermeneutic Study | OKCIR: Omar ... - December 19th, 2018
- G. I. Gurdjieff Famous Mystics Great People - December 10th, 2018
- George Gurdjieff | Be Community | George Gurdjieff | Be ... - December 7th, 2018
- Pythagoras, Gurdjieff and the Enneagram - Enneagram Monthly - November 21st, 2018
- Gurdjieff - The Rochester Folk Art Guild - November 21st, 2018
- Gurdjieff Research Papers - Academia.edu - October 8th, 2018
- Gurdjieff - Simple English Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - July 22nd, 2018
- Gurdjieff: Life is real only then, when 'I am' - Being ... - July 2nd, 2018
- Ancient Wisdom | Gurdjieff Becoming Conscious - May 25th, 2018
- Gurdjieff Teaching | Gurdjieff Becoming Conscious - March 30th, 2018
- When Crowley Met Gurdjieff | Martin Aurelio - March 16th, 2018
- Gurdjieff & Fritz Peters, Part I The Gurdjieff Journal - March 2nd, 2018
- George Gurdjieff - Religious Figure - Biography - February 9th, 2018
- George Gurdjieff - Religious Figure - Biography.com - December 28th, 2017
- Gurdjieff's Teaching of The Fourth Way - December 15th, 2017
- Gurdjieff, A Beginner's Guide: How Changing The Way We React ... - December 10th, 2017
- Gurdjieff's Mission - YouTube - December 8th, 2017
- New to this Work? Start Here | Gurdjieff Becoming Conscious - November 28th, 2017
- Gurdjieff - Rare Remarkable - YouTube - November 28th, 2017
- George Gurdjieff | OSHO | Meditation - Mindfulness and the ... - October 17th, 2017
- The Gurdjieff Society - About Gurdjieff - October 17th, 2017
- Gurdjieff & Fourth Way - Watkins Books - October 17th, 2017
- The Gurdjieff Legacy Foundation: George Ivanovitch Gurdjieff ... - October 9th, 2017
- Gurdjieff Books | Gurdjieff Becoming Conscious - August 28th, 2017
- Spiritual scholar Ravi Ravinda to speak at Hawkwood College in ... - Stroud News and Journal - August 28th, 2017
- Gurdjieff Becoming Conscious | Gurdjieff Becoming ... - August 25th, 2017
- Frederick Woodruff * Astrology * Gurdjieff * Fourth Way ... - August 6th, 2017
- Fourth Way - Wikipedia - August 6th, 2017
- Backstage | Gurdjieff Becoming Conscious - August 6th, 2017
- Sam Shepard obituary - The Guardian - August 6th, 2017
- Gurdjieff Work - The Fourth Way, Maurice Nicoll, Spiritual ... - June 15th, 2016
- G.I. Gurdjieff (Author of Meetings With Remarkable Men) - June 10th, 2016
- G. I. Gurdjieff - Life and Controversy - June 9th, 2016
- ALL AND EVERYTHING - George Gurdjieff - April 10th, 2016
- Gurdjieff Sacred Dance - Movement 11 - YouTube - November 2nd, 2015
- Georges Ivanovi Gurdjieff - Wikipedia - November 2nd, 2015
- Black Sheep Philosophers - Gurdjieff - October 5th, 2015
- Gurdjieff Internet Guide - September 16th, 2015
- Fourth Way - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - September 16th, 2015
- Peter Brook and Traditional Thought - Gurdjieff - September 16th, 2015
- Georges Gurdjieff Wikipdia - September 16th, 2015
- George Gurdjieff - Wikipedia, la enciclopedia libre - September 16th, 2015