Triumph of faith in Ayodhya verdict set to test SC in its Sabarimala review – ThePrint
Posted: November 18, 2019 at 8:44 pm
Text Size:A- A+
New Delhi: After delivering the big-ticket Ayodhya verdict Saturday, the Supreme Court will weigh in on another issue of faith this week whether women aged 10-50 should be allowed into the sanctum sanctorum of Keralas Sabarimala temple.
The court had last year allowed women inside the temple, triggering widespread protests in Kerala. The upcoming verdict deals with around 65 review petitions filed against the 2018 order, including by the National Ayyappa Devotees (Women) Association, the Nair Service Society, and the All Kerala Brahmins Association.
However, a lot seems to have changed in the observations of the court between 2018 and 9 November 2019, when the disputed site of Ram Janmabhoomi in Ayodhya was set aside for a temple. Notably, the court stated last year that faith and belief could not be grounds to deprive someone of their Right to Equality. Last week, however, the court said it was beyond the ken of judicial inquiry to determine whether a belief is justified.
The question of worship also elicited a different reading from the two benches.
Given that precedent plays a big role in the Indian judicial system, the differences in observations between 2018 and 2019 may hold clues to how the Sabarimala verdict could play out this week.
The Ayodhya title suit sought to decide who among Hindus and Muslims owns the Ram Janmabhoomi.
The Sabarimala case, meanwhile, pertains to the faith of Lord Ayyappa devotees, who believe the deity was celibate and hence had to be away from women of the menstruating age group.
Ruling on the matter by a 4:1 majority, a Constitution bench of the Supreme Court allowed women of all ages inside the sanctum sanctorum. Prohibition of their entry, the majority verdict ruled, was a violation of the Right to Equality and not part of Article 25, which guarantees the Right to Practice ones religion.
Justice Indu Malhotra, the lone woman on the bench and the sole dissenter, observed that it was not for courts to interfere in matters of religion. It must be left to those practising the religion, she said.
A similar refrain animated the Ayodhya verdict delivered by another Constitution bench Saturday the bench ruled that matters of faith and belief lie in the personal realm of the believer. Whether a belief is justified lies beyond ken of judicial inquiry, it added.
That which sustains solace to the soul is inscrutable. Whether a belief is justified lies beyond the ken of judicial inquiry, it said. Once the witnesses have deposed to the basis of the belief and there is nothing to doubt its genuineness, it is not open to the court to question the basis of the belief, the court added.
Faith is a matter for the individual believer. Once the court has intrinsic material to accept that the faith or belief is genuine and not a pretence, it must defer to the belief of the worshipper.
Also read: In echo of Sabarimala dissent, SC junks plea seeking entry of Muslim women in mosques
Hindus believe the disputed site in Ayodhya is the birthplace of deity Ram. Devotees of Ayyappa believe he was celibate.
While the belief of Ayyappa devotees was dismissed as the court opened the sanctums doors to all women, that of Ram worshippers was upheld in the Ayodhya judgment.
Even though Hindus were not in exclusive possession of the inner courtyard (site where the mosque was), the court said, they continued prayers at the contested site, convinced that Ram was born there.
It was this faith that led to a judgment in favour of a temple.
The Ayodhya and Sabarimala cases both involve the consideration of the deity Ram and Ayyappa, respectively as a separate legal person. However, in the Ayodhya case, the act of worship itself was considered a legal entity.
The bench, led by CJI Ranjan Gogoi, said the Muslim side presented no evidence to prove continued worship at the mosque between its construction in 1528 and 1856-7, when the British built a brick wall around it to prevent communal tensions.
However, the Hindus, the court said, continued to pray at the area, even after the wall was built, thus proving exclusive possession.
The court noted that juristic rights are not conferred on an idol but on devotees worship to the deity concerned for a continued period of time.
In the case of Hindu idols, legal personality is not conferred on the idol simpliciter but on the underlying pious purpose of the continued worship of the deity as incarnated in the idol, it said. Where the legal personality is conferred on the purpose of a deitys continued worship, moving or destroying the idol does not affect its legal personality, the verdict added.
In the Sabarimala case, heard by a Constitution bench led by former CJI Dipak Misra, worship was not given juristic status, with the bench ruling that religious practice (worship) could not be exclusionary in nature.
Petitioners who wanted the bar on women to continue argued that the deity was a legal person and could excercise his fundamental rights, which meant his celibate character ought to be respected.
However, Justice D.Y. Chandrachud who concurred with the majority but penned a separate verdict noted that a deity can only be a juristic person for the purposes of religious law and not to claim fundamental rights allowed for persons under the Constitution.
Also read: Two readings of Ayodhya verdict: legalising Hindutva or separating site from structure
Some of the lawyers who appeared for the petitioners seeking womens entry into the Sabarimala sanctum do not see the Ayodhya verdict having a bearing on the case.
Senior lawyer Shekhar Naphade said the Ayodhya verdict was driven by evidence, not faith.
In Ayodhya, it was a title suit nothing to do with religion. Faith was not the basis but it was the evidence that was the crux of the Ayodhya verdict, the lawyer added.
Senior lawyer V. Giri said the Ayodhya case was somewhere about faith but added that the facts of both cases were completely different.
On 6 February, a five-judge Constitution Bench led by CJI Ranjan Gogoi and comprising Justice R.F. Nariman, Justice A.M. Khanwilkar, Justice D.Y. Chandrachud and Justice Indu Malhotra, had reserved the verdict on the Sabarimala verdict. It is supposed to be decided this week, before Gogoi retires 17 November.
Also read: Next door to Sabarimala temple district, a menstruating goddess is worshipped
ThePrint is now on Telegram. For the best reports & opinion on politics, governance and more, subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram.
More:
Triumph of faith in Ayodhya verdict set to test SC in its Sabarimala review - ThePrint
- Norway cancels allied exercise over COVID-19 safety concerns - The Independent Barents Observer - February 1st, 2021
- Rwanda registers yet another record number of new Covid cases in a day - The New Times - February 1st, 2021
- 'Clippers need to trade Paul George; he thinks he is the man': Shaquille O'Neal on why Kawhi Leonard... - The Sportsrush - October 30th, 2020
- The ASX robotics stocks looking to capitalise on the rise of the machines - Stockhead - October 30th, 2020
- Big Homes Just Listed in the Coulee Region - Winona Daily News - September 4th, 2020
- The U.S. Air Force Showcases Another Amazing Week In Photos - HotCars - September 1st, 2020
- Can ageing really be 'treated' or 'cured'? An evolutionary biologist explains - The Conversation AU - August 12th, 2020
- Can Ageing Really Be Treated or Cured? An Evolutionary Biologist Explains - Gizmodo Australia - August 12th, 2020
- Excercise Bike Market 2020:Key market Insights, Drivers and Restraints, Opportunities and Challenges, Sales and Revenue and Forecast Period... - July 7th, 2020
- Excercise Bike Market Share, Growth, Trend Analysis and Forecast from 2020-2026; Consumption Capacity by Volume and Production Value|BH Fitness, BH... - July 7th, 2020
- The Supreme Court made the wrong call on public aid for religious schools - Herald and News - July 7th, 2020
- Caution is the key as grandparents start to mix with grandchildren again as lockdown rules are eased - Eastern Daily Press - July 7th, 2020
- Big Homes Just Listed in the Coulee Region - Kenosha News - May 29th, 2020
- Time for Christians to Prove the Faith We Are Made up of - THISDAY Newspapers - May 25th, 2020
- Lifting Lockdown and the Veil of Ignorance - bellacaledonia.org.uk - May 25th, 2020
- 2 thoughts on More Terrible Keyboards That Nonetheless Work - Hackaday - May 24th, 2020
- Alh Usman Shagadi: The end of an era - Vanguard - May 24th, 2020
- Kathryn proud of being bow-legged - Journal Online - May 24th, 2020
- Unions threaten legal action to have SAA business rescue practitioners removed - Fin24 - April 30th, 2020
- London weather: Here's when 24C heat will arrive in your part of London - MyLondon - April 23rd, 2020
- A Guide For Seniors On Coping In The Age Of Coronavirus - LAist - March 21st, 2020
- Coronavirus: Italy tightens restrictions as death toll tops 4,000 - Wanted in Rome - March 21st, 2020
- PM tells nation not to panic over virus - myRepublica - March 21st, 2020
- #WeApplaud: French pay tribute to health workers from their balconies - FRANCE 24 English - March 21st, 2020
- Today at the news stands - GhanaWeb - March 21st, 2020
- Watch: Deprived of football, players try to fill the 'big void' - Times of Malta - March 21st, 2020
- Mier arraigned in circuit court on threat of terrorism charges relating to bank robbery case - Ogemaw County Herald - March 15th, 2020
- Kerala Man Suspected Of Coronavirus Flees Isolation Ward, Brought Back Within Hours - NDTV News - March 15th, 2020
- Police to conduct training exercise in Kilbirnie - Stuff.co.nz - February 14th, 2020
- Ladki Haath Se Nikal Jayegi: When Will Society Retire This Phrase? - SheThePeople - January 22nd, 2020
- Invershin hall launches health and wellbeing festival - Northern Times - January 21st, 2020
- What is coronavirus and how worried should we be? - Sydney Morning Herald - January 21st, 2020
- Caution advised as Storm Brendan arrives in Limerick - Limerick Leader - January 13th, 2020
- Beating the Blue Monday Blues - Adhithy, Newstead Wood - News Shopper - January 13th, 2020
- Virginia Tech Hokies lead the Kentucky Wildcats by a Slim 3 Points - Gobbler Country - January 3rd, 2020
- Kourtney Kardashian Is Responding To Criticism From Fans On Twitter Over Daughter's Birthday Party - Yahoo Entertainment - November 20th, 2019
- DILEMMA OF THE MANKIND - Daily Pioneer - November 18th, 2019
- London to Sydney flight breaks world record - CNN - November 18th, 2019
- Scenic Coast to Craft Run: an epic first for the Bay! - RNews - November 18th, 2019
- Locally Sourced at PNB is a Mixed Bag of Very Highs and Also Some LowsPretty Much Like Life! - seattlepi.com - November 18th, 2019
- Let's not waste our right to vote on November 5 - The Courier-Express - November 2nd, 2019
- Leah Bracknell dismissed smoking as cause of her lung cancer in emotional chat - Irish Mirror - October 20th, 2019
- Why You Should Consider Meditation - April 5th, 2019
- Manchester United announce plans for ring of steel around their Carrington training ground - Manchester Evening News - September 6th, 2017
- Readers' comments: 'Demonetisation does not seem to have been a fruitful exercise' - Scroll.in - September 4th, 2017
- Operation Nanook hits Labrador: An inside look as soldiers train for the north - CBC.ca - August 25th, 2017
- Outdoor bike cinema where you cycle to keep the movie playing coming to Wallington next month - Croydon Advertiser - August 25th, 2017
- Combivent aer boeh - Is there a generic combivent - You Know I Got Soul - August 25th, 2017
- Colts Notebook: Injuries dominant at training camp - The Herald Bulletin - August 18th, 2017
- PD patients: Excercise your body and mind - Desert Dispatch - August 17th, 2017
- Excercise your brain - Del Rio News Herald - August 17th, 2017
- Ajanta pharma kamagra soft tabs picture - Kamagra soft tablets review - Filipino Express - August 16th, 2017
- Colts' Sheard attempting to put new spin on old tricks - The Herald Bulletin - August 8th, 2017
- New spin on old tricks - The Rushville Republican - August 8th, 2017
- Free Excercise Classes and Senior Medicare Patrol - Montclair NJ ... - TAPinto.net - August 5th, 2017
- Vast majority of Scottish children not meeting excercise guideline - The Scotsman - August 4th, 2017
- 920th Rescue Wing, 45th Space Wing Conduct Joint Active Shooter Excercise, Response - SpaceCoastDaily.com - August 4th, 2017
- Kamagra oral jelly for sale in south africa - Kamagra oral jelly for sale in durban - The Maravi Post - August 1st, 2017
- A taste of firefighting: Camp shows women skills of fire service - Nashua Telegraph - July 30th, 2017
- To your Good Health: Choose a better diet and excercise regimen for health - Prescott Daily Courier - July 30th, 2017
- Emergency Excercise On The Campus Of St. Cloud State University - KVSC-FM News - July 11th, 2017
- Baylor School Tennis: Kevin Donovan is New Boys ad Girls Head Coach - The Chattanoogan - July 9th, 2017
- Emma Rigby visits Northern Kenya 3 months on from the East Africa ... - Mareeg Media - July 8th, 2017
- Terra's Secret Revealed as Deathstroke's Titans Team Assembles - CBR (blog) - July 6th, 2017
- Fund bosses welcome indy directors, but warn of talent shortage - Citywire.co.uk - July 5th, 2017
- Tips to Help Millburn Pets Stay Safe on July 4th - TAPinto.net - July 5th, 2017
- LARGEST MERCHANDISE LIQUIDATION SALE IN OHIO 8/5/2017 - Digital Journal (press release) - July 5th, 2017
- Deputies: Boaters in Cayuga County told to excercise caution on - WSYR - July 5th, 2017
- We are ready for Osun Senatorial Bye Election INEC, NYSC, security agencies - BusinessDay (satire) (press release) (registration) (blog) - July 5th, 2017
- Emma Rigby visits Northern Kenya 3 months on from the East Africa crisis appeal - Mareeg Media - July 3rd, 2017
- Inmate charged over prison stabbing - Bay 93.9 - July 3rd, 2017
- Taos Parade of Homes - Weekly Alibi - July 1st, 2017
- Ex-boyfriend charged after Kent student has 'throat slit' at busy shopping centre - The Independent - July 1st, 2017
- Browns Ferry Nuclear Plant Emergency Excercise - whnt.com - July 1st, 2017
- Colorado Avalanche Choosing Not to Qualify Mikhail Grigorenko is Tomfoolery - Mile High Sticking - June 27th, 2017
- It's 120 degrees in Phoenix -- and inmates at a local jail have to sleep outside - AOL - June 26th, 2017
- Sycamore Park District back in expansion mode with community center - DeKalb Daily Chronicle - June 24th, 2017
- Hospital staff 'rise to challenge' in chemical spill exercise at Hull Royal Infirmary - Hull Daily Mail - June 24th, 2017
- NFL star joins volunteer effort for new playground - Sun Sentinel - June 24th, 2017
- Temperatures to hit 30s on parts of Vancouver Island this weekend - CTV Vancouver Island - June 24th, 2017