Inconvenient truths: Potholes along the yellow brick road of LGBTQ history – LGBTQ Nation
Posted: October 19, 2019 at 1:46 pm
Errors in published histories, misreading, selective perception, willful historical fiction on the big screen, little screen, and web; alternative facts simply made up to suit various agendas; and the desire to believe what some wish to be true have created a constantly reverberating echo chamber of false knowledge which George Bernard Shaw warned is more dangerous than ignorance.
This post is an antidote for some of it.
Related: In 1919, the first pro-gay movie was made. A year later, it was banned.
The origin of faggot
Faggot as a male homosexual slur did not derive from burning gays at the stake. The word is English and did not evolve from another language. England hanged but did not burn gays at the stake as some other countries did. Its first known published gay connotation appeared in 1914s A Vocabulary of Criminal Slang: All the fagots (sissies) will be dressed in drag at the ball tonight.
Any connection to the firewood used for executions is pure fantasy, says Word Myths: Debunking Linguistic Urban Legends, 2004.
Victims included Bishop John Atherton and his alleged lover John Childe; both hanged in 1640.
Lieutenant Frederick Gotthold Enslin
The few details actually documented about American Revolutionary War Lieutenant Frederick Gotthold Enslin continue to generate ever more amplified, ever more colorful retellings based solely on speculation and wishful thinking.
He was not thrown out of the Continental Army for being gay nor being homosexual nor homosexuality nor for his sexual orientation in 1778.
Those are states of being, and we know nothing of his sexual orientation. He was thrown out for same-sex behavior, but that doesnt tell us his motivation. He could have simply been pursuing sexual release with another man because a woman wasnt available as men in the military or prison or all-boys schools have for eternity.
But, contrary to ubiquitous assertions that behavior was not sodomy. He was charged with and found guilty of attempting to commit sodomy. While General George Washingtons secretary recorded the abhorrence and detestation of such infamous crimes, there was no reference to, let alone definition of, sodomy in the 5th Article 18th Section of the Articles of War which he was charged with violating.
Thus we have nothing to tell us which of the several things that accusation could have meant it actually did mean in this case.
It could have meant attempting to force sex (of whatever kind) upon someone; apparently in this instance from the scanty records, Pvt. John Monhort. It could also mean consensual attempted anal sex but without completing penetration, and, as gay historian Rictor Norton has noted, the phrase was sometimes used to encompass completed consensual same-sex acts other than anal intercourse such as fellatio.
Nor, contrary to assertions, was he dishonorably discharged because the term didnt exist yet.
Nor, as often claimed, was his sword broken over his head. The diary entry of an eyewitness to his drumming out, Lt. James McMichael, mentioned only that the coat of the delinquent was turned wrong side out. The phrase drumming out used metaphorically today was literal then. The regiments drum and fife corps played while the condemned exited the camp.
Maj. Gen. Frederich Wilhelm von Steuben
Articles exist asserting that both Benjamin Franklin and General Washington unequivocally knew that German Maj. Gen. Frederich Wilhelm von Steuben was gay and that his hiring proved they were ahead-of-their-time Friends of the Gays. Some justify the assertion by referencing late author Randy Shilts and his lengthy study of gays in the American military, Conduct Unbecoming.
Actually Shilts wrote: The acceptance of General Steuben and his contributions to the fledgling American military did not mean there was even tacit acceptance of homosexuality by Franklin or Washington.
If they actually knew about his sexuality, his employment was still more a matter of war, like politics, making strange bedfellows, no pun intended. Nor, contrary to the misreading of documents of the time, was von Steuben fleeing possible prosecution in France but, rather, his native Germany.
Oscar Wilde
Oscar Wilde was certainly a gay martyr, but he was not a gay rights trailblazer who refused to deny his identity. He denied it multiple times over three trials; repeatedly insisting that his attachment to the various men linked to him was not sexual but only deep spiritual affection that is as pure as it is perfect.
The first gay magazine in the world
Der Eigene, first published in Berlin in 1896, was not the worlds first homosexual journal nor was it initially a homosexual periodical at all. Originally it was an anarchist magazine, not becoming EIN BLATT FR MNNLICHE KULTUR (A Journal for Male Culture) until 1898. Along with articles and poems, apparently it was the first periodical to feature nude photographs of men intended for gay subscribers.
The first gay periodical was published by German Karl Heinrichs Ulrichs in 1870: Prometheus Beitrge zur Erforschung des Naturrthsels des Uranismus und zur Errterung der sittlichen and gesellschaftlichen Interessen des Urningthums (Prometheus. Contributions to the investigation of the riddle of nature Uranismus and to the discussion of the moral and social interests of Urningthum). His hopes for subsequent issues failed for lack of adequate subscribers.
Franklin Roosevelt and homophobia
Claims that then-Assistant Secretary of the Navy Franklin Roosevelts June 1917 article in the Ladies Home Journal, What the Navy Can Do for Your Boy, was exploiting the publics great fear of homosexual influence on American young men are contradicted by one of the articles photos a group of sailors on the U.S.S. Pennsylvania with the caption, Your Boy Would Not be Lonely on a Battleship.
Nor, contrary to persistent outraged claims, did Roosevelt create or order or use his own staff for the 1919 gay witch-hunt at Newport, Rhode Islands, Naval Training Station.
Such assertions reveal the failure of the authors of such claims to carefully read Lawrence Murphys original research on the witch-hunt published in 1988 as Perverts by Official Order.
It was instigated at the Newport base by a pathologically homophobic but persuasive Chief Machinists Mate not in Washington by Roosevelt and had been going on nearly a month before Roosevelt was even told about it. Those in Newport did not need his permission but only approached his boss, Secretary of the Navy Josephus Daniels, because they needed funding to continue. Daniels was leaving on a trip to Europe and told Roosevelt to meet with them.
Yes, his subsequent support was homophobic, but his later adamant denials that he had not known, let alone approved, sailors being told to engage in gay sex to entrap their victims, Navy and civilian, is credible, particularly given he had tried unsuccessfully to get the Justice Department to take over the investigation.
Lili Elbe reality check
As noted in my earlier article about Christine Jorgensen, Danish Girl Lili Ilse Elvenes/Lili Elbe was not the first person to have gender confirmation surgery. Her first operation in 1930 was supervised by legendary gay sexologist Dr. Magnus Hirschfeld in Berlin who had been involved in such surgeries since at least 1906.
Dr. Magnus Hirschfeld, the Institute for Sexual Science, and book burning
Demonized for years as the Jewish Apostle of Sodomy, the mob attack on Hirschfeld that nearly killed him some newspapers did report his death happened in Munich in October 1920, not Berlin in May 1933 when a Nazi-affiliated youth group ransacked his Institute for Sexual Science.
Time and again one reads that the Institute and all of its contents were subsequently burned or destroyed. While most of the thousands of confiscated books, photos, and others items were burned, some of the materials were strangely held back and offered for sale through intermediaries back to Hirschfeld who was in Paris by then.
Further, anticipating such threats, his former lover Karl Giese had smuggled some of the most important documents out of the country.
Nor were all of the materials about homosexuality or gender identity. The Institute studied heterosexuality, too, and had a large medical practice for such things as contraception, infertility, and impotence. Nor was that the only book burning that day
A May 10, 1933, Associated Press article, along with several others, reported, Proscribed volumes [were] collected all over Germany for public burning blacklisted books from private as well as public libraries of ungerman influences All books of a socialistic, Jewish or Pacifist trend are especially marked for destruction.
The authors the article specifically named whose works were included were Helen Keller and Albert Einstein, neither of which, to the best of my knowledge, were L or G or B or T.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Beware of false knowledge; it is more dangerous than ignorance. George Bernard Shaw.
Read the original:
Inconvenient truths: Potholes along the yellow brick road of LGBTQ history - LGBTQ Nation
- Nice walks in Welwyn Garden City and Wheathampstead - Welwyn Hatfield Times - February 17th, 2021
- Irish unity will take place within a generation historian Max Hastings - The Irish Times - February 17th, 2021
- Viola Davis says she had to make her Blackness disappear as a student at Julliard - The News International - February 17th, 2021
- Press Review: Climate Change by Bill Gates and the Anti-Q Lobby - News - haveeruonline - February 17th, 2021
- Viola Davis: Dark-Skinned Black Women Do Not Have The Same Freedom As White Actresses - SheThePeople - February 17th, 2021
- Ireland Reads campaign leads up to national day to celebrate reading on 25 February - TheMayor.EU - February 17th, 2021
- Princestan is many pages of revelations: Jairam Ramesh - The Siasat Daily - February 17th, 2021
- Love is in the air and on the screen for Valentine's Day - Monadnock Ledger Transcript - February 17th, 2021
- George Bernard Shaw Was so Enamored with Socialism He Advocated Genocide to Advance It | Tyler Curtis - Foundation for Economic - February 17th, 2021
- Dublin pubs: Lego artist recreates the citys iconic boozers with tiny bricks - Dublin Live - February 10th, 2021
- On this day: February 9 - Metro Newspaper UK - February 10th, 2021
- Allyson Pollock: Testing, testing...for SARS-CoV-2 in asymptomatic people - The BMJ - The BMJ - February 10th, 2021
- Artist Spotlight: Bored at My Grandmas House - Our Culture - Our Culture Mag - February 10th, 2021
- The life and greatest quotes of George Bernard Shaw, Nobel Prize and Oscar winner - IrishCentral - February 10th, 2021
- Saint Joan: Speaking Truth to Power | Music | yesweekly.com - Yes! Weekly - February 9th, 2021
- Dover Doins: Heroes all around in our community - Foster's Daily Democrat - February 9th, 2021
- To er is human Frank McNally on the scourge of rhotic imperialism - The Irish Times - February 9th, 2021
- Fabulous Online And IRL Events This Week: Feb. 8 - 11 - LAist - February 9th, 2021
- Thinking Anew A universal and timeless significance - The Irish Times - February 9th, 2021
- AMERICAN THEATRE | The Sardonic, Curious, Unyielding John Heilpern - American Theatre - February 9th, 2021
- Dennis Marek: I wish I had thought of that - Kankakee Daily Journal - February 9th, 2021
- Getting old is like climbing a mountain; you get a little out of breath, but the view is much better - The Dubrovnik Times - February 9th, 2021
- Theater groups present plays virtually to stay connected to audiences - Uniontown Herald Standard - December 28th, 2020
- Politicians and statesmen . . . and their reading habits - The Financial Express - December 28th, 2020
- My Bond girl should have turned down sex with 007, says Gemma Arterton - The Sun - December 28th, 2020
- Patty Hearst's Daughters Now: Where Are Lydia and Gillian Hearst Today? Update - The Cinemaholic - December 28th, 2020
- 6 new hotels to seek out in the UK and Ireland in 2021 - NewsChain - December 28th, 2020
- Muhammad (pbuh), the Best of Mankind - Kashmir Reader - December 28th, 2020
- Patty Hearst Now: Where is She Today? Is She in Jail? Update - The Cinemaholic - December 28th, 2020
- The cosmic explorations of Elon Musk, David Bowie and Blind Willie Johnson - Colorado Springs Independent - December 3rd, 2020
- The French law protecting those who speak funny is a real crime - Telegraph.co.uk - December 3rd, 2020
- Theater groups present plays virtually to stay connected to audiences - Observer-Reporter - December 3rd, 2020
- Mural inspired by Toy Show's Adam is a gesture of hope - RTE.ie - December 3rd, 2020
- Christopher Plummer Films and Interviews Coming To Stratfest@Home - Broadway World - December 3rd, 2020
- Marion Davies was as big as Valentino. Then she had a scandalous affair - The Irish Times - December 3rd, 2020
- J.C. Bose Father of Radio Science who was forgotten by West due to his aversion to patents - ThePrint - December 3rd, 2020
- Op-Ed: Rules For Revolutionaries: Understanding The Transformative Events That Are Reshaping America - The Published Reporter - December 3rd, 2020
- The Return of Nature and Marx's Ecology - Monthly Review - December 3rd, 2020
- Letter to the Editor: What used to be the party of Lincoln - Daily Bulldog - November 24th, 2020
- Letter to the Editor: First socialism, then communism - North Platte Telegraph - November 24th, 2020
- Is Joe Biden the new RFK? - The Philadelphia Citizen - November 24th, 2020
- The vaccines are on their way. Our next task? Persuade people to take them - Evening Standard - November 24th, 2020
- Village Playhouse Has Run Planned Through June, 2021 - Shepherd Express - November 24th, 2020
- Signs of the times: "Wagnerism: Art and Politics in the Shadow of Music" by Alex Ross - Santa Fe New Mexican - November 24th, 2020
- On this day: November 18 - Metro Newspaper UK - November 24th, 2020
- It happened today - this day in history - November 18 - Yellow Advertiser - November 24th, 2020
- GO NZ: New Zealand's best hot springs, geysers and geothermal attractions - New Zealand Herald - November 24th, 2020
- We dont have it right: Bay Area sports teams struggle to diversify leadership - San Francisco Chronicle - November 24th, 2020
- Renewable Energy Technologies Are Impacting the Oil and Gas Future - Energy Voice - November 11th, 2020
- Inside One Madmans Wild Plan to Conquer Everest - InsideHook - November 11th, 2020
- Are Hotels Only to Stay or Does it Have a Story to Reveal? - Love Belfast - November 11th, 2020
- Chelsea: The criticism of Kai Havertz is premature and unwarranted - The Pride of London - November 11th, 2020
- The kidnapping and brainwashing of newspaper heiress Patty Hearst - 9Honey - November 11th, 2020
- Life Without Art In A Pandemic - New Haven Independent - October 9th, 2020
- The Skelligs: the Islands of wonder, legend and lore - Irish Examiner - October 9th, 2020
- Students resurrect old uniforms to mark schools 175th anniversary - The Irish Times - October 9th, 2020
- Northern Light Theatre has something special to celebrate - St. Albert TODAY - October 9th, 2020
- Kirby: What they say, what they mean and what can you do? - The Augusta Chronicle - October 9th, 2020
- Britains mixed-race population blurs the lines of identity politics - The Economist - October 9th, 2020
- In the Mendelssohn Octet, the pure sound of youth - Los Angeles Times - October 9th, 2020
- Naval Service Will be Required to Deal with Tensions if Brexit Talks fail to Broker Deal On Fishing Rights - Afloat - October 9th, 2020
- 'What Are You Saying? And why you're not saying it' - a new book by Conor Kenny - Limerick Post - October 9th, 2020
- England is still a nation divided by language says VIRGINIA BLACKBURN - Daily Express - October 9th, 2020
- Shes All That: Tanner Buchanan joins the cast of gender-flipped Shes All That remake - Gamer Rewind - October 9th, 2020
- Navy to Carry Out Investigation Over Fire On Board LE Niamh - Afloat - October 9th, 2020
- Pod of the Planet Ep. 9: Not Everyone is Greta, and That's OK - Pod of the Planet - State of the Planet - September 2nd, 2020
- Opinion | Why writing is harder than you think - Livemint - September 2nd, 2020
- Stellar Lumens (XLM) Community Fund 2.0 to be a New and Improved Version - The Cryptocurrency Analytics - September 2nd, 2020
- Television: C-SPAN offered some of the best convention coverage - The Delaware County Daily Times - September 2nd, 2020
- My Heart's in the Highlands: Today is William Saroyan's 112th birth anniversary - Public Radio of Armenia - September 2nd, 2020
- Noted educator and architect William Bill McMinn passes away at 89 - The Architect's Newspaper - September 2nd, 2020
- Kilkennys Butler Gallery breaks from castle basement home - The Irish Times - August 22nd, 2020
- Why Mwalimu Bukenyas students have kept the faith - Daily Nation - August 22nd, 2020
- A List of Books, Plays and Films to Illuminate Your Understanding of the Suffragist Movement - Sarasota - August 22nd, 2020
- Did you know about our sister magazine Ireland of the Welcomes? - IrishCentral - August 22nd, 2020
- The Ethical Argument For Wearing a Face Mask - The National Interest - August 22nd, 2020
- A Timeline of Notable Events Leading to the Passage of the 19th Amendment - Sarasota - August 22nd, 2020
- Candid Confession: The fault lies with our parents - National Herald - August 22nd, 2020
- The Abolition of Man and the Advent of the Posthuman - Discovery Institute - August 22nd, 2020
- Garry Linnell: Angry old men rule, and are ruining, the world - The New Daily - August 22nd, 2020