Are Vegan "Butter" and "Meat" Labels Protected as Free Speech? – The Regulatory Review
Posted: December 10, 2020 at 7:55 am
U.S. courts seem to recognize plant-based companies constitutional right to use meat and dairy advertising terms.
Is it constitutional to label a vegan product as butter? You butter believe itor, at least, that is how several U.S. courts have responded in ongoing cases.
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) places federal requirements on food product labels, but FDA does not pre-approve labels before they enter the market. Although states often rely on FDA to clarify labeling standards, some states institute standards stricter than FDAs federal ones.
For example, Californias false-advertising law, which may be the strictest in the country, imposes a burden on companies to show that a label is not likely to deceive members of the public. As a result, companies must comply proactively with both federal and state laws, and vegan food companies and advocates, in particular, have often found themselves in court arguing that state law restricts their labeling options beyond the extent allowed by federal constitutional law.
In the most recent case as of this writing, a federal trial court has grappled with a vegan food companys claim that the First Amendment protects its use of the term butter against interference by California regulators. Vegan food companies have viewed an early ruling in the case as a victory with significant industry-wide implications.
The case originated in a warning letter that the California Department of Food and Agriculture sent to Miyokos Kitchen in 2019, advising the vegan food company that its butter labels were misbranded under FDA requirements and the California Food and Agriculture Code. This state code restricts the use of dairy-based language and imagery on imitation dairy product labels. In turn, Miyokos Kitchen sued the state, arguing that the Department sought to chill its free speech and had bowed to pressure from dairy industry lobbyists. In September, the court barred the Department from taking any enforcement action against the companys use of the terms butter, lactose free, or cruelty free on its labels.
Although the ruling was only preliminary and the case will not proceed to a full trial until 2021, the courts decision to protect Miyokos Kitchens use of butter terminology sparked both excitement and frustration. The Animal Legal Defense Fundcelebrated the decision for its implications for smaller vegan companies, which rely on terms such as butter and milk to market their products uses to consumers.
But other commentators, including the National Milk Producers Federation, complain that the butter sold by plant-based companies is simply margarine with better marketing. They claim that FDA has a responsibility to stop this rampant margarine mislabeling. After all, most vegan butter products fit neatly into FDAs definition of margarine.
The Miyokos Kitchen lawsuit is only the latest battle in U.S. butter wars, which have raged for over a century between the dairy industry and producers of dairy alternatives such as margarine. Historically, six dairy-dominated states banned margarine outright, multiple states imposed extra taxes on butter alternatives, and 32 states regulated the color of margarine, forcing producers to dye it an unappetizing pink, red, brown, or black color rather than butter yellow.
The U.S. Supreme Court struck down the pink laws in 1898, and the last state to maintain a ban on yellow margarine repealed that law in 1967. Still, the dairy and meat industriesand the states that host themare eager to regulate against vegan companies use of terms such as butter and burger. In 2019, for example, Mississippi passed a law prohibiting the use of meat product terms to describe plant-based foods.
But plant-based companies have started fighting back against such restrictions. The Plant Based Foods Association and the Institute for Justice immediately challenged the Mississippi law in court. The groups weaponized the First Amendment to argue that companies have a protected right to use the terms veggie burger and vegan hot dog on their labels, as these phrases do not mislead consumers. The groups also suggested that if companies were forced to change their labels, consumer confusion would increasebecause alternative terms, such as veggie discs or vegetable protein tubes, are not very clear.
The lawsuit prompted Mississippi to replace the law less than four months after it became effective. A new proposed Mississippi state regulation specifies that plant-based meat products will not be considered mislabeled as long as their labels include an adjective such as meatless, plant-based, or vegan.
In a similar example, a federal trial court blocked the state of Arkansas from enforcing a law that prohibits plant-based meat producers from using the word meat and related terms. In 2019, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) and the Good Food Institute sued the state, claiming that the law violated a vegan companys rights under the First Amendment and the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The court rejected the states argument that plant-based meat product labels are misleading even if they include ample terminology indicating their vegan or vegetarian nature. The court also blocked the law from taking effect while the case proceeded to trial.
The outcomes of the Miyokos Kitchen and ACLU lawsuits may impact the growth of the plant-based foods industry, which is expanding quickly. The Good Food Institute values the U.S. plant-based butter industry at $198 million, a figure that presently far outpaces the growth of the dairy butter industry. Between 2018 and 2020, U.S. sales of plant-based foods surged by 29 percent, and a study projects that the worldwide plant-based food sector will be worth $74.2 billion by 2027. But as the court noted in the Miyokos Kitchen case, each vegan company dealing with labeling disputes may have to spend millions of dollars if regulations or court decisions require label changes.
Lawsuits concerning plant-based products may also be relevant to the coronavirus crisis. Due to COVID-19s disruption of supply chains, some milk intended for butter production is being dumped. The Good Food Institute claims that the supply chains for vegan alternatives are better poised to respond to pandemic conditions, as they are less vulnerable to disruptions typical to animal agriculture. Although FDAs relaxation of some labeling rules during COVID-19 has increased plant-based products access to the market, court decisions requiring label changes could reverse this trend.
By creating clearer regulations as to the labeling of vegan products, FDA could melt away many of the conflicts between plant-based food companies, state regulators, and lobbying groups. But given FDAs recent budget cuts and chronic underfunding, as well as the demands of the COVID-19 crisis, FDA priorities seem to lie elsewhere. In the agencys absence, the U.S. judicial system seems poised to continue cutting through these regulatory issues like a hot knife through butteror vegan butter, as it may be called.
Continued here:
Are Vegan "Butter" and "Meat" Labels Protected as Free Speech? - The Regulatory Review
- Katy Perry Shared That She's Going Totally Vegan Soon - Delish.com - January 19th, 2021
- Kamala Harris' Ancestral Indian Village to Celebrate Inauguration with Vegan Feast - VegNews - January 19th, 2021
- These Companies Are Making Vegan-Friendly Breakfast More Exciting - Thrillist - January 19th, 2021
- A New Black Woman-Owned Vegan Caf Is Coming to Alabama - VegNews - January 19th, 2021
- Here is The Best Vegan Restaurant in Every State in the US - The Beet - January 19th, 2021
- Vegan Deli & Butcher Is Suddenly Closed After Successful "Taco Hell" Pop-Up - Riverfront Times - January 19th, 2021
- "I'm ready to be 100% vegan", Katy Perry tells 109 million followers - Vegan Food and Living - January 19th, 2021
- Katy Perry Announces That She's "Ready to Be 100 Percent Vegan" - The Beet - January 19th, 2021
- Kite Hill Just Launched Vegan Yogurts that Mimic Dairy - VegNews - January 19th, 2021
- From Greek Nachos to Acorn Squash and White Bean Stew: Our Top Eight Vegan Recipes of the Day! - One Green Planet - January 19th, 2021
- Is Wine Vegan? What You Need to Know (Plus 7 to Try) - Plant Based News - January 19th, 2021
- Greenpoints Xilonen Bolts Out of the Gate With Stunning Vegan Mexican Fare - Eater NY - January 19th, 2021
- Pamela Anderson and Piers Morgan argue over whether vegans have better sex - Yahoo Sports - January 19th, 2021
- This Black-Owned Vegan Grocery Store to Open Locations in Every Major US City by 2024 - VegNews - January 19th, 2021
- Oatly launches petition to stop plant-based censorship on vegan dairy alternatives - Vegan Food and Living - January 19th, 2021
- Recipe: Try these delicious vegan cauli-wings that rival BrewDog's buffalo version - Press and Journal - January 19th, 2021
- 9 Ways to Build a Vegan Beauty Routine - Vogue - January 19th, 2021
- Beyond Meat Exec and Top Chef Alum Partner to Create Vegan Jerky to Help the Planet - VegNews - December 10th, 2020
- Vegan Pop-Up Plant Based Papi Is Opening a Full-Blown Restaurant This Month - Eater Portland - December 10th, 2020
- Nice Cream Truck will deliver vegan milkshakes to Tampa Bay in 2021 - I Love the Burg - December 10th, 2020
- Going vegan? Switching to a plant-based diet to improve your health? You are almost 50% more likely to suffer bone fractures - Genetic Literacy... - December 10th, 2020
- 12 Vegan Candy Options to Satisfy Your Sweet Tooth - Healthline - December 10th, 2020
- From Lemon Bars to Sweet Potato Miso Soup: Our Top Eight Vegan Recipes of the Day! - One Green Planet - December 10th, 2020
- Hot Cocoa Charcuterie Boards Are Trending: How to Veganize Them - The Beet - December 10th, 2020
- Eating Vegan During The Holidays - kiss951.com - December 10th, 2020
- Tyson's Raised & Rooted Range Is Now Vegan - LIVEKINDLY - December 10th, 2020
- 15 Vegan Holiday Recipes 2020 15 Vegan Holiday Recipes No One Will Even Suspect Are Healthy - Cosmopolitan - December 10th, 2020
- Assessing eye problems, walking and life expectancy, heart and mind, vegan bone issues, eat early - nwitimes.com - December 10th, 2020
- A Full Day of Vegan, Homecooked Meals That Don't Break The Bank - Daily Nexus - December 10th, 2020
- Supplementing vegan diet with the right nutrients - Times of India - December 10th, 2020
- Atlanta's Slutty Vegan is having its best year ever during a pandemic - Fast Company - December 10th, 2020
- 6 Fabulous Vegan Cakes You Can Pick Up at the Grocery Store - VegNews - December 10th, 2020
- Addictive Vegan Recipes and No BS: Get to Know 'The Korean Vegan' - LIVEKINDLY - December 10th, 2020
- McDonalds McPlant Isnt The Fast Food Giants First Vegan Sandwich - Forbes - December 10th, 2020
- Miyoko's Is Giving Away a Year's Worth of Vegan Cheese - VegNews - December 10th, 2020
- Food Fare: Create vegan versions of holiday fare - Times-Mail - December 10th, 2020
- Black vegans are carving their own identity - Kansas City Pitch - December 10th, 2020
- From Eton Mess to Bean and Beet Burgers: Our Top Eight Vegan Recipes of the Day! - One Green Planet - December 10th, 2020
- Von Holzhausen, Vegan Leather, & Helping The Homeless While Promoting Sustainability - CleanTechnica - December 10th, 2020
- Biospringer Introduces New Source of Vegan Protein From Yeast Fermentation - vegconomist - the vegan business magazine - December 10th, 2020
- Seven new vegan cookbooks that perfectly suit this unusual year - pressherald.com - December 10th, 2020
- These Sneakers Are Made With Vegan Suede Used in Luxury Cars - The Beet - December 10th, 2020
- So What Is Vegan Beauty And Is it Worth A Try? - Longevity LIVE - Longevity LIVE - November 27th, 2020
- Vegan diets may be linked to a higher risk of bone fractures - Medical News Today - November 27th, 2020
- Graeter's Introduces New Line of Vegan Ice Creams - Cleveland Scene - November 27th, 2020
- Exposed Vegan opens healthy food options along West Boulevard - Charlotte Post - November 27th, 2020
- Craving Burgers, Chinese, or Burritos? You Can Order Them All From This New Vegan Concept in Los Angeles - VegNews - November 27th, 2020
- Charo Urges Fans to Have a Vegan Thanksgiving - VegNews - November 27th, 2020
- Food truck startup cooks up Southern-style favorites with vegan spin - RichmondBizSense - November 27th, 2020
- THIS and Coughlans Bakery Team Up to Launch UK's First Vegan Bacon Wellington - VEGWORLD Magazine - November 27th, 2020
- From Baklava Custard Tart to Protein-Packed Chocolate Chia Pudding: 10 Vegan Recipes that Went Viral Last Week! - One Green Planet - November 27th, 2020
- The best vegan gifts are in this vegan holiday gift guide - Vegans, Baby - November 27th, 2020
- Cam Newton explains his vegan, turkey-less Thanksgiving feast - MassLive.com - November 27th, 2020
- Vegan Thanksgiving dishes everyone will love - Los Angeles Times - November 27th, 2020
- Vegan Cam Newton Reveals His Plant-Based Thanksgiving Menu - The Beet - November 27th, 2020
- Give Thanks for These Vegan Thanksgiving Day Recipes - Times of San Diego - November 27th, 2020
- Vegan Thanksgiving In Redondo Beach: Recipes Without The Bird - Patch.com - November 27th, 2020
- 6 Chefs Share Their Favorite Vegan Holiday Recipes - Vogue - November 27th, 2020
- Vegan Protein Bar Market 2020 Global Industry Analysis, Trends, and Forecast 2026: CiToxLAB, Charles River, Bureau Veritas, Criver, Envigo, Thermo... - November 27th, 2020
- Global vegan cheese market to reach $4.42 Billion by 2027: Allied Market Research - GlobeNewswire - November 27th, 2020
- Mike Tyson Says Becoming Vegan Helped Him Cut down Weight from over 300 Pounds - EssentiallySports - November 27th, 2020
- Kickstart your week with this healthy vegan meal plan recommended by a registered dietician - Insider - INSIDER - November 27th, 2020
- How To Enjoy Thanksgiving As A New Vegan - MadameNoire - November 27th, 2020
- Tabitha Brown Cooks Vegan Jackfruit Pot Roast on Red Table Talk with Jada Pinkett Smith - VegNews - November 27th, 2020
- Where to Pick up Vegan Thanksgiving Pies in Los Angeles - VegOut Media LLC - November 27th, 2020
- This (Vegan) Sneaker Is Made Using the Same Material as Ferraris - Highsnobiety - November 27th, 2020
- From milkweed to wool in Auroville - The Hindu - November 27th, 2020
- Is a vegan diet right for you? Heres everything you need to know - TODAY - October 16th, 2020
- Here Are 9 Vegan Nutritionists and Dietitians We're Following - VegNews - October 16th, 2020
- Vegan vs. Dairy-Free: What's the Difference? - Healthline - October 16th, 2020
- What Are Some of the Best Vegan Protein Powders on the Market? - Green Matters - October 16th, 2020
- Kroger Launches 50 New Vegan Products, Including Its Own Chicken, Cheese, and Oat Milk Ice Cream - VegNews - October 16th, 2020
- Booker 'outs' Cruz as vegan; Cruz jokingly decries 'scurrilous attack' | TheHill - The Hill - October 16th, 2020
- Vegan Brand Forager Project Switches Packaging to Urge Customers to Vote - VegNews - October 16th, 2020
- Vegan Babybel Cheese Is Coming to US Next Year - VegNews - October 16th, 2020
- These Vegan Business Owners Are All Kids - LIVEKINDLY - October 16th, 2020
- From Chocolate Crunch Bars to Pumpkin Protein Bars: Our Top Eight Vegan Recipes of the Day! - One Green Planet - October 16th, 2020
- Vegan Fashion Week launches the worlds first fully vegan showroom - FashionUnited UK - October 16th, 2020
- Vegan Food Is Driving the Growth of the Frozen Food Market to $65 Billion by 2024 - VegNews - October 16th, 2020
- The 100 Best Vegan Products of All Time - VegNews - October 16th, 2020