Retired UW computer science professor embroiled in Twitter spat over AI ethics and cancel culture – GeekWire
Posted: December 22, 2020 at 7:00 pm
University of Washington computer science professor emeritus Pedro Domingos. (UW Photo)
The University of Washington computer science department denounced comments made online by a retired professor over a debate about AI ethics, Timnit Gebrus controversial exit at Google, so-called cancel culture, and more.
A heated back-and-forth involving longtime AI researcher Pedro Domingos and the response from the UW demonstrates the complexity of public discourse on controversial topics. It also highlights unanswered questions related to the societal implications of artificial intelligence, and is the latest example of the backlash that can occur when politics collides with academia and the tech industry.
Domingos, who joined the UW faculty in 1999 and is the author of The Master Algorithm,sparked the initial discussion on Twitter after hequestioned why the Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS) conference was using ethics reviews for submitted papers.
Its alarming that NeurIPS papers are being rejected based on ethics reviews,' he tweeted last week. How do we guard against ideological biases in such reviews? Since when are scientific conferences in the business of policing the perceived ethics of technical papers?
His opinion drew a number of responses from other top data scientists and those involved with NeurIPS.
The problem here is that folks like him lack the humility to admit that they do not have skills in qualitative work and dismiss it all as a slippery slope,' tweeted Rumman Chowdhury, founder of Parity and former global lead for Responsible AI at Accenture Applied Intelligence. Qualitative methods have rigor. Ethical assessment can be generalizable and sustainable.
The discourse on Twitter then shifted to last years decision to rename NeurIPS. There were concerns over the previous name NIPS due to racial slurs and sexism.
That set off the beginning of a long exchange between Domingos and Anima Anandkumar, a professor at Caltech and director of machine learning research at NVIDIA who led a petition to change the name of the conference. Pornography came up in a discussion about web search results for the term nips, sparking a response from Katherine Heller, chair of diversity and inclusion for NeurIPS 2020, and Ken Anderson, chair at the University of Colorados computer science department.
As of Tuesday, Anandkumars Twitter was no longer active. She declined to comment for this story.Update:Anandkumar posted a public apology on her blog Wednesday. She also said she deactivated her Twitter account in the interest of my safety and to reduce anxiety for my loved ones.
NeurIPS posted a statement on ethics, fairness, inclusivity and code of conduct on its homepage. Weve reached out to the conference for comment.
Having observed recent discussions taking place across social media, we feel the need to reiterate that, as a community, we must be mindful of the impact that statements and actions have on our peers, and future generations of AI / ML students and researchers, it reads. It is incumbent upon NeurIPS and the AI / ML community as a whole to foster a collaborative, welcoming environment for all. Therefore, statements and actions contrary to the NeurIPS mission and its Code of Conduct cannot and will not be tolerated.
The Twitter chatter also delved into the recent departure of Gebru, a top AI ethics researcher at Google, and whether she was fired by the company or resigned following a controversy related to an AI ethics paper. Domingos tweeted that Gebru was creating a toxic environment within Google AI and said that she was not fired, despite Gebru stating otherwise.
Heller then tweeted at Domingos and said he was violating the NeurIPS code of conduct.
Later that evening, the UWs Allen School of Computer Science and Engineering issued a lengthy statement via Twitter. The schools leadership took issue with Domingos engaging in a Twitter flame war belittling individuals and downplaying valid concerns over ethics in AI, and for his use of the word deranged. Heres the statement in full:
#UWAllen leadership is aware of recent discussions involving Pedro Domingos, a professor emeritus (retired) in our school. We do not condone a member of our community engaging in a Twitter flame war belittling individuals and downplaying valid concerns over ethics in AI. We object to his dismissal of concerns over the use of technology to further marginalize groups ill-served by tech. While potential for harm does not necessarily negate the value of a given line of research, none of us should be absolved from considering that impact. And while we may disagree about approaches to countering such potential harm, we should be supportive of trying different methods to do so.
We also object in the strongest possible terms to the use of labels like deranged. Such language is unacceptable. We urge all members of our community to always express their points of views in the most respectful and collegial manner.
We do encourage our scholars to engage vigorously on matters of AI ethics, diversity in tech and industry-research relations. All are crucial to our field and our world. But we are all too familiar with counterproductive, inflammatory, and escalating social-media arguments.
We have asked Pedro to make clear he tweets as an individual, not representing the Allen School or the University of Washington. We would further argue that this whole mode of discourse is damaging and unbecoming.
The Allen School is committed to addressing AI ethics and equity in concrete ways. That work is ongoing, and many of our activities are listed on our website.
One key component is to expand the inclusion of ethics in our curriculum and prepare students to consider the very real impact that technology can have, especially on marginalized communities.
In recent years, we have added multiple classes on this topic at both the graduate and undergraduate levels, and we plan to continue to work toward expanding that aspect of our curriculum.
As a school, we have stated our commitment to be more inclusive and to consider the impact of our work on people and communities. We will not be deterred, by naysayers inside or outside of our community, from putting in the hard work required to achieve those aims.
Signed, Members of the Allen School Leadership Magdalena Balazinska, Prof. and Director Dan Grossman, Prof. and Vice Director Tadayoshi Kohno, Prof. and Associate Director for Diversity, Equity & Inclusion Ed Lazowska, Prof. and Associate Director for Development & Outreach
Domingos described the schools response as cowering before the Twitter mob.
We followed up with Magdalena Balazinska, a well-regarded researcher and educator who took over as the Allen School director last year. Heres what she had to say about the matter:
As leader of the Allen School, one of my highest priorities is to promote a culture and an environment that is diverse, equitable, and inclusive. I also deeply care about an environment in which people discuss issues, even potentially controversial ones, openly, with empathy, and without bullying. Witnessing what happened on Twitter this past week was disheartening. We need to find ways to come together. The entire tech industry should work toward all these goals, and we have much work to do.
Ed Lazowska, a longtime leader at the Allen School, said the department is committed to academic freedom and freedom of speech.
We encourage good-faith dialogue, including on controversial issues, he said. But we expect members of our community to engage in that dialogue in a respectful, collegial, and constructive manner that is free from personal attacks and is not dismissive of peoples lived experiences. Pedro failed to live up to those standards and we felt compelled to make clear where we stand.
Lazowska added: Pedro is within his rights to tweet. We felt it was important to distance the school from his views.
In an email exchange with GeekWire, Domingos said the Allen School should have stood by my right to voice my opinions, and back me up in my efforts to free the machine learning community from the miasma descending on it.
Instead, they chose to pay their obeisance to the ultra-left crowd, as they have before, Domingos said, referencing Stuart Reges, another UW computer science professor who was criticized for his 2018 essay that claimed women are underrepresented in software engineering because of personal preference, not because institutional barriers deter them from pursuing careers in tech.
Reges told GeekWire he was disappointed that the Allen School has thrown Pedro under the bus.
He has raised significant questions about the activism surrounding Timnit Gebrus termination from Google and new efforts to inject ethics reviews into all aspects of AI research, said Reges. The greatest sin he has committed has been to refer to deranged activists. The unified mob reaction to try to cancel him proves that his opponents and the Allen School leadership are not willing to engage in meaningful dialog to explore the issues.
Domingos said the Twitter spat highlights how the machine learning community is being progressively strangled by political correctness and extreme left-wing politics.
The larger problem is that academia and the tech industry, not just machine learning, are being strangled by a crowd that refuses to allow the free exchange of ideas on which research depends, and is successfully imposing an increasingly far-left orthodoxy, he told GeekWire. People live in fear of their attacks.
Daniel Lowd, an associate professor at the University of Oregon who earned his PhD from the UW in 2010, tweeted that he would like to publicly disavow and distance myself from these comments by my PhD advisor and collaborator.
The reaction to Domingos original tweet about ethics reviews of AI papers also reflects the pressing dilemma of AI ethics as the technology increasingly infiltrates everyday life.
Considering the ethical impact of AI research is absolutely essential, said Oren Etzioni, a UW computer science professor emeritus (retired) who is now CEO of Seattles Allen Institute of Artificial Intelligence.
That said, its hard to argue with Pedros observations about online attacks and the refusal to allow the free exchange of ideas, said Etzioni, who noted that he was speaking to GeekWire as an individual and not a representative of any institution.
Etzioni called out a platform his father launched called Civil Dialogues that encourages deliberation on pressing issues. He also noted his Hippocratic oath created in 2018 as a way to encourage AI software developers to remember their ethical burden.
Asked about Domingos comments on Twitter, Seattle University senior instructor and AI ethics expert Nathan Colaner said it seems that his underlying attitude is that ethical concerns in AI are overblown, and that ethicists are making too much of their concerns, specifically when it comes to algorithmic bias.
I think thats the wrong attitude to have, Colaner said. First of all, there is no legitimate debate to be had about whether algorithms are neutral. It is also now clear that AI is not going to remove human bias, as we sometimes used to hear. But what is still unclear is whether human bias is a worse or less bad problem than algorithmic bias.
Colaner said there are plenty of unanswered questions that need answers as AI innovation continues at a rapid pace. The AI ethics community is basically scrambling, he said, adding that he supports the Allen Schools statement. Colaner is managing director of the Initiative in Ethics and Transformative Technologies, an institute at Seattle U made possible through a donation from Microsoft.
Healthy debate sharpens everyones minds, Colaner said, but since we in the AI ethics community have serious, time-sensitive work to do, distraction is not useful, which is why Twitter made the unfollow button.
The rest is here:
Retired UW computer science professor embroiled in Twitter spat over AI ethics and cancel culture - GeekWire
- Ask Larry: Will Changes In The Full Retirement Age Reduce My Social Security Benefit At 70? - Forbes - December 22nd, 2020
- 5 Unexpected Sources of Retirement Income -- All Related to Your Home - Motley Fool - December 22nd, 2020
- Considering retirement? Here's why you need to talk about it. A lot. - Minneapolis Star Tribune - December 22nd, 2020
- 3 Moves to Make Right Now if You Want to Retire Early - The Motley Fool - December 22nd, 2020
- Dont Miss These CARES Act Retirement Benefits - Forbes - December 22nd, 2020
- Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer, 82, says he will retire 'eventually': 'Hard to know exactly when' - Fox News - December 22nd, 2020
- Don't forget to check your retirement plan. Here are moves to make before the year is out - CNBC - December 22nd, 2020
- Its Time to Change How We Talk about Retirement, Starting with the Word Itself - Kiplinger's Personal Finance - December 22nd, 2020
- LeBron on course to join legends with jerseys retired by multiple teams - NBA.com - December 22nd, 2020
- I'm retired and won't live to see my mortgage paid off. Should I refinance to lower my monthly payment? - MarketWatch - December 22nd, 2020
- Scarborough superintendent plans to retire at the end of June - pressherald.com - December 22nd, 2020
- Katie Compton winding down storied career, will retire in 2022 - Cyclingnews.com - December 22nd, 2020
- How This Couple Retired At 55 With Just $200,000 In Their Roth IRA Account - Yahoo Finance - December 22nd, 2020
- There Are 5 Types of Retirement Savers, New Research Says. Which One Are You? - Barron's - December 16th, 2020
- IRA Guru Ed Slott On Taxes, Retirement & Roth IRAs - Forbes - December 16th, 2020
- Soothing the Retirement Fears of Middle-Class Millionaires - ThinkAdvisor - December 16th, 2020
- Center for Retirement Research: Public pension plans should avoid investing based on social and environmental movements - Yankee Institute - December 16th, 2020
- Tesla Fever: Understanding Index Funds And How They May Hurt Your Retirement - Forbes - December 16th, 2020
- Grand Forks School Board weighs budget reduction, early retirement concerns - Grand Forks Herald - December 16th, 2020
- Andy King to Retire From Arrow Electronics, Inc. - Business Wire - December 16th, 2020
- Top Ford labor negotiator Gary Johnson to retire after 34 years - Detroit Free Press - December 16th, 2020
- Northam to spend $100 million to reduce teacher retirement liabilities - Richmond.com - December 16th, 2020
- Beware these 15 worst states for taxes on your retirement - Yahoo Finance - December 16th, 2020
- 4 pieces of advice to help you retire comfortably, according to people who have done it - Business Insider - December 16th, 2020
- Common Mistakes That Could Derail Your Retirement and How to Avoid Them - Barron's - December 16th, 2020
- Can You Retire a Millionaire With Index Funds? - The Motley Fool - December 16th, 2020
- A Happier Retirement Could Be Yours if You Do These Things - Journal Gazette and Times-Courier - December 16th, 2020
- Report: This Is How Much It Costs to Retire Happy - The Motley Fool - November 27th, 2020
- Retirement reform likely slips to 2021 as Washington finalizes end-of-year spending - Yahoo Finance - November 27th, 2020
- Man fatally shot by relative in FishHawk Ranch home could be retired Marine officer - Tampa Bay Times - November 27th, 2020
- The 10 Best Places to Retire in America - Money - November 27th, 2020
- Pedro Hernandez, retired justice of the peace, dies - Billings Gazette - November 27th, 2020
- Cover Your Biggest Retirement Expense With $300 Monthly in This ETF - Waco Tribune-Herald - October 19th, 2020
- I want to retire next year, but I have $25,000 in credit card debt and a major monthly mortgage payment I also live with my three kids and ex -... - October 19th, 2020
- With interest rates near record lows, retirement may have to wait - Quartz - October 19th, 2020
- 60% of Medicare enrollees worry about health care costs. Here's the best way to pay for them in retirement - USA TODAY - October 19th, 2020
- These are the 5 best places to retire in America - CNBC - October 19th, 2020
- Forget the Rent, Collect the Yield: Why Investors Looking to Retire Early Should Consider REITs - Barron's - October 19th, 2020
- 4 good ways to go broke in retirement - Fox Business - October 19th, 2020
- Americans Are Facing a $3.83 Trillion Retirement Shortfall. Here's What to Do About It - North Platte Telegraph - October 19th, 2020
- Will There Be an End-of-Year Retirement Exodus? - GovExec.com - October 19th, 2020
- How much you need to invest every month to retire with $1 million to $3 million, broken down by age - CNBC - October 19th, 2020
- South Africas unusual electrical plugs, sockets to be retired - Quartz Africa - October 19th, 2020
- A $5,500 withdrawal from your 401(k) could cost you $30,000 - USA TODAY - October 19th, 2020
- 'Blazing the pathway': Retired teacher could become Kansas' first transgender lawmaker - NBC News - October 19th, 2020
- 5 ways HR can help millennials be smarter than their parents about retirement - Employee Benefit News - October 19th, 2020
- Siouxland veterans and service men and women honor retired flags - KTIV - October 19th, 2020
- Im 63, my husband is 70, well have $90,000 a year in retirement how can we claim our Social Security benefits? - MarketWatch - October 19th, 2020
- Retirement investors: Why it's time to stop using the 4% rule - Fox Business - September 30th, 2020
- Regs on retirement-payment withholding updated - Accounting Today - September 30th, 2020
- Empower to buy Fifth Third's $6 billion retirement business - InvestmentNews - September 30th, 2020
- Retirement Savers: 4 Easy Investing Strategies to Implement Now - SCNow - September 30th, 2020
- Need another income stream? Here are 5 reasons to invest in dividend-paying stocks for retirement. - USA TODAY - September 30th, 2020
- 8 Ways to Save for Retirement as a Freelancer - Entrepreneur - September 30th, 2020
- If you're saving for retirement and are in your 50s, it may be time to reassess your plan - CNBC - September 30th, 2020
- This lesser-known retirement savings tool is loaded with tax benefits - Fox Business - September 30th, 2020
- Op-ed: The pandemic has forced firms to offer early retirement plans. Heres what to consider before you decide to pack it in - CNBC - September 30th, 2020
- Even Seniors Who Are Good Savers Stand to Fall Short in Retirement, Report Concludes - Barron's - September 30th, 2020
- Women's Health Care Costs in Retirement Projected to be $200000 More than Men's - Business Wire - September 30th, 2020
- Trinseo Announces the Retirement of Stephen M. Zide and Christopher D. Pappas from Its Board of Directors - Business Wire - September 30th, 2020
- 5 Reasons to Invest in Dividend-Paying Stocks for Retirement - The Motley Fool - September 30th, 2020
- Gardner Fire Chief Richard Ares honored on the eve of his retirement as U.S. Rep. Lori Trahan officially announces $240K grant for his department -... - September 30th, 2020
- Here's what your monthly budget will look like if you retire with $2 million - CNBC - September 30th, 2020
- Parmer to retire as Baptist CEO after more than 30 years - Beaumont Enterprise - September 30th, 2020
- 3 Pitfalls of Only Using a 401(k) for Retirement - The Motley Fool - September 30th, 2020
- Whats your takeoff point? The moment youve saved enough for retirement - The Dallas Morning News - September 30th, 2020
- Your retirement probably won't be anything like your parents'...and that's not good news - MarketWatch - September 23rd, 2020
- This study finds that those who retired early lost brain power - MarketWatch - September 23rd, 2020
- With remote work flexibility, some people opt to relocate ahead of their retirement - CNBC - September 23rd, 2020
- My grandma's secret to a comfortable retirement for the past 22 years - Business Insider - September 23rd, 2020
- Most Americans are behind on their retirement savingshere are some tips to catch up - CNBC - September 23rd, 2020
- Retirement is coming, but it won't be smooth sailing - WATN - Local 24 - September 23rd, 2020
- If youre home-rich but cash-poor, heres what to know about reverse mortgages - CNBC - September 23rd, 2020
- Here's how to take the mystery out of picking the best retirement savings plan for you - CNBC - September 23rd, 2020
- CalSavers will help people save for retirement. What to know - Los Angeles Times - September 23rd, 2020
- College-Based Retirement Communities Have Been Upended by Covid. Are They Still Worth It? - Barron's - September 23rd, 2020
- 3 things to do immediately if you have no retirement savings - Fox Business - September 23rd, 2020
- What NOT to do with your retirement savings in a crisis - MarketWatch - September 23rd, 2020
- Fortis Inc. Announces Retirement of President and CEO Barry Perry and Appointment of David Hutchens as Successor Effective January 1, 2021 -... - September 23rd, 2020
- National Institutes of Health staffer to 'retire' after being outed as author of online attacks against Dr. Anthony Fauci - USA TODAY - September 23rd, 2020