One Man’s Trash, Another Man’s Tradition – Earth Island Journal
Posted: November 12, 2020 at 5:57 pm
In Vietnams Red River, navigating the space between environmental conservation and cultural preservation can be trickier than it first appears.
November 11, 2020
On a chilly, gray January morning in Hanoi, Vietnam, a local development worker named Anh Ngoc Thi Nguyen volunteered at a river clean-up at the Red River near Chuong Duong Bridge. Keep Hanoi Clean (KHC), a nonprofit funded by USAID, had organized a crew of nearly two dozen volunteers to form a human chain, passing sack after sack of trash from the riverbank to a small parking lot beneath the bridge. KHC organizers planned to remove over 11 tons of garbage.
But when Nguyen noticed that some of the sacks contained ceramic incense bowls and urns, and waterlogged bits of wooden altars, she refused to take part. I didnt want to touch them, she says. It was scary.
In Hanoi, almost every house and storefront has its own wooden altar. Twice a month and on special occasions, residents offer food, alcohol, and cigarettes in the altars as a gift for their ancestors. When homeowners move, tradition dictates they must discard that house altar in a large body of water. Many in Hanoi choose to throw the altar and its contents from one of the many bridges that span the Red River.
Nguyens family members rigorously follow the many customs and traditions passed down to them by their elders. When Nguyens fathers body was reinterred, for example, her mother threw the ceramics that sat on top of his former grave into the river not far from where they lived. Nguyen and her family believe that those ceramics belong to the spirits of their ancestors and the water helps to carry them away.
The altars and offerings represent just one small part of the pollution picture on the Red River. Once the lifeblood of Hanoi, the river, through years of unfettered dumping of plastic waste, illegal sand mining, and industrial runoff, has become a symbol of the degradation caused by rapid industrial development.
At the KHC cleanup site, a debate ensued among volunteers on whether or not the discarded urns and altars represented spiritual artifacts to leave alone, or if they should be disposed of alongside the trash clogging the river. Ultimately, the events coordinator and KHCs founder, James Kendell, decided that these artifacts would be removed.
Watching KHC remove these artifacts from the river made Nguyen feel unsettled. Why couldnt they just leave them where they were? she asked later. They werent hurting anyone.
This debate on the Red River is a microcosm of a much larger question of how we balance environmental activism and cultural traditions. A 2013 paper in the Journal of Cleaner Production estimates that each year, more than 2 million pilgrims to Mecca emit 60.5 kilograms each of carbon dioxide per day (as opposed to a global average of just under 14 kilograms per person per day) during their pilgrimage as a result of transportation and lodging.
During the Lunar New Year, the Chinese set off fireworks to ward away evil spirits. In 2018, Beijings air quality soared above 500 on the Air Quality Index due to this tradition. Anything over 50 is considered unsafe.
And each year, during Christmas time, the United Kingdom produces 30 percent more waste than usual, air travel around the world spikes, and 540,000 tons of wrapping paper fill Canadian landfills.
In Hanoi, Keep Hanoi Clean has been trying to figure out how to navigate its programs with consideration to cultural practices on the Red River. According to Doug Snyder, KHCs general director, up until the January volunteer event, the nonprofits policy has always been to leave spiritual artifacts where they lay.
In previous years we did not touch the urns because one of the people on our team told us not to, he says.
But now, the organization is changing course.
Diep Ngoc Bui, chief operating officer at KHC, says complaints against river clean-ups mostly come from older people for whom the custom of immersing altars, ashes, and other sacred items in rivers is heavily ingrained. Bui says in these situations she tries to explain why the ceramics and altars should not be thrown into the river in the first place. But that tactic is not always successful.
Its really hard to tell the older generation you shouldnt throw these things into the river, she says. [They believe] its going to affect their business or health of the family, the rest of the year. Its really a delicate issue.
We really have to get on the education side, says Snyder. Unless we put out some information about giving them an alternative thats less destructive, then theyll just keep doing it.
Snyder says there are plans to consult with members of the local Buddhist community to help to initiate a public education program.
Thich Tinh Giac is a Buddhist monk and reformist who runs Chua Phuc Son, a buddhist pagoda just outside of Hanoi. He says that people throwing religious artifacts into Hanois waterways have got it all wrong. He says the idea that this practice brings good fortune is all superstition.
It does not, he says, have any significance in the Buddhist faith.
Giac also makes one other important observation: He notes that the Vietnamese people have historically been poor. They could not traditionally afford to make sacrifices the size and scope of those they make now.
The GDP per capita of Vietnam has increased six-fold since the year 2000. As a result, per-capita consumption has also increased, and Vietnam is now the worlds fourth largest contributor to ocean plastic waste, producing an estimated 730,000 tons each year.
Snyder has made a similar observation. At one cleanup event, he and a Vietnamese volunteer confronted two women who had been throwing plastic flowers into the river. Snyder and a Vietnamese volunteer then collected the flowers.
It was kind of like a comedy skit, Snyder says. But then one of them got really upset.
A conversation about the origins of the practice for this woman ensued.
What did you put in the water in the past? asked the Vietnamese volunteer.
Well, we didnt put this kind of stuff in, the woman replied. We were too poor but now were rich.
In other words, a big issue that Snyder and the KHC staff are dealing with is how plastic waste has infiltrated a cultural practice.
Of course, this may seem a minor issue given the bigger problems facing the Red River. Admittedly, KHCs work is somewhat piecemeal given the size and scope of the environmental challenges facing Vietnam, such as mining, urban and industrial runoff, and rampant corruption and top level apathy toward environmental issues that hinder any form environmental activism that goes beyond picking up rubbish.
This is particularly true when money is involved. For example, in May, a local newspaper called Phu Nu TPHCM (HCMC Women) tried to expose a local developer for damaging Vietnams natural heritage. As a result, the newspaper was fined and its website taken offline for a month. Advocacy can be risky when it jeopardizes profits.
So KHC is doing its best to clean up the river by picking the safer option: working with local traditions to find a solution that helps the river.
Luckily, Giac says that support for these practices is waning, particularly as Buddhist leaders occupy an important role in society.
Because I am a monk, they believe me, they respect me, Giac says. At his pagoda he has urns he has retrieved that he now uses to grow plants. He says repurposing rather than destroying the bowls makes a lot more sense.
In this vein, Giac says he has an important role to play in helping to save Hanois waterways. He often confronts worshippers in the process of making their offerings and counters that Buddhist doctrine actually supports protecting the environment.
In Buddhism, we say, you reap what you sow, he says. So the environment, you look after it and over time you get good results.
More:
One Man's Trash, Another Man's Tradition - Earth Island Journal
- Happening this week: Queer Climbing Night, Basics of Buddhism and more - Vail Daily News - February 1st, 2021
- How Durga images and sculptures showed up in Ghazni, Afghanistan - ThePrint - February 1st, 2021
- Explained: What are the amendments in Thailands abortion law? - The Indian Express - February 1st, 2021
- Dying 'the Buddhist way' gains in hospice centers in the West - Religion News Service - November 12th, 2020
- Buddhist thought and practice: an exploration | Columnists - Herald Review - November 12th, 2020
- Buddhist Nuns and Their Crusade for Recognition in Southeast Asia - VICE - November 12th, 2020
- The Angsty Buddhist: Chronic Pain & Trying Not To Be A White Yoga Lady - Autostraddle - November 12th, 2020
- Meet Thich Nhat Hanh, the man behind Escondido's famed Deer Park Monastery - The San Diego Union-Tribune - November 12th, 2020
- China wants to build a Tibet with more wealth and less Buddhism - Livemint - October 30th, 2020
- Buddhist Insights on Peace & Love, Hosted by the Peacemakers - The All State - October 30th, 2020
- The Angsty Buddhist: Learning Anger And White Buddhism - Autostraddle - October 30th, 2020
- Days After 230 Dalits Accepted Buddhism In UP, FIR Registered Over "Conversion" Rumour | HW English - HW News English - October 30th, 2020
- Miracle Grow: Zen in the Mulch Pit - Splice Today - October 30th, 2020
- India to spend $15 million to boost Buddhist ties in region - ABC News - October 3rd, 2020
- The Return of the Pope of Buddhism Scepter by His Holiness Dorje Chang Buddha III was Rejected - PRNewswire - October 3rd, 2020
- Do a temple stay at the headquarters of Soto Zen Buddhism - Japan Today - October 3rd, 2020
- Catholics spread joy to disabled Buddhist children in Vietnam - UCAN - October 3rd, 2020
- Travelling to Indias Himalayan frontiers? Heres why you see fluttering colored flags and stone stacks - The Financial Express - October 3rd, 2020
- Sikkim to establish new Buddhist university in accordance with National Education Policy guidelines -... - The Sentinel Assam - October 3rd, 2020
- NFU: Understanding the spirit and intent of the Lands Protection Act - TheChronicleHerald.ca - October 3rd, 2020
- The True Nature of Self: A Live-Streaming Buddhist Retreat - Patch.com - October 3rd, 2020
- Understanding the spirit and intent of Lands Protection Act - peicanada.com - October 3rd, 2020
- Looper column: The role of desire in the religious life - Sentinel-Standard - September 4th, 2020
- Prof. Stephen Long stresses recognition of Buddhist in the US - Asian Tribune - September 4th, 2020
- Buddhist nun challenges hatred of women - The Star Online - September 4th, 2020
- Where Buddhist mindfulness and Black activism meet - Vox.com - July 6th, 2020
- Buddhist Temple Archway Preserved in High Detail with Artec 3D Scanning - 3DPrint.com - July 6th, 2020
- THE FIFTH OF JULY: A Buddhist Analysis of What's Wrong, and What Might be Right. - Patheos - July 6th, 2020
- VICE - This Beatboxing Buddhist Monk Is Out to Change Perceptions of Spiritual Music - VICE - July 6th, 2020
- Gautam Buddha gave his first sermon on Guru Purnima: A look at some of his teachings and quotes - Times Now - July 6th, 2020
- Review: The Buddha and the Borders by Nirmalaya Banerjee - Hindustan Times - July 6th, 2020
- How Many Dragon Balls Are There in The Original Manga? - Screen Rant - July 6th, 2020
- Young Japan priests try to breathe life into fading Buddhism - Religion News Service - June 14th, 2020
- Confluence of ideas - Chinadaily.com.cn - Chinadaily USA - June 14th, 2020
- 5 Facts To Know About The Future Of Buddhism - World Atlas - June 14th, 2020
- Emily Temples The Lightness Spins a Mystery Around Troubled Teen Girls at Summer Camp - Observer - June 14th, 2020
- Indian philosophy helps us see clearly, act wisely in an interconnected world - The Conversation US - June 14th, 2020
- COVID-19 and the link between religious practices and personal health - Deseret News - June 14th, 2020
- Japanese art and rinpa: Buddhism, Maple trees, and a lovely stone lantern - Modern Tokyo Times - June 14th, 2020
- Montaigne to perform at the Art Gallery of New South Wales for Make Music Day - Aussievision - June 14th, 2020
- Don Farber, Visions of Buddhist Life by Andy Romanoff - The Eye of Photography - May 26th, 2020
- Susy Powlesland obituary - The Guardian - May 26th, 2020
- Water, reciprocity, and the anthropocene in the Himalayas - Advanced Science News - May 26th, 2020
- The robot does the hard work. Can you still attain enlightenment? - MIT Technology Review - February 21st, 2020
- Open hearts: The Buddhist approach to love and loving - Irish Examiner - February 21st, 2020
- Simon Walker invests the grand resign of living in the now - Newcastle Herald - February 21st, 2020
- Buddhist conference to be attended by 21 countries - Himalayan Times - February 21st, 2020
- Solitude in Buddhism | The Art of Solitude - Tricycle - February 1st, 2020
- Race and Class in Buddhism: A Vision of What Could Be - Tricycle - February 1st, 2020
- Buddhism and Relationships: Love at First Sit - Tricycle - February 1st, 2020
- How to Read the Lotus Sutra: A Guide for the Uninitiated - Tricycle - February 1st, 2020
- Investigating the Mind: What Buddhism Says About Our Likes and Dislikes - Tricycle - February 1st, 2020
- Cycles of Motherhood by Barbara Gates - Tricycle - February 1st, 2020
- The Gandharan manuscripts change what we know about the course of Buddhist history - Scroll.in - February 1st, 2020
- Liberate: Why Julio Rivera Created a Meditation App for People of Color - Tricycle - February 1st, 2020
- When Religion Kills lives up to the hype - The Kingston Whig-Standard - February 1st, 2020
- The American Jewish Romance with Buddhism - Mosaic - January 7th, 2020
- Ernest & Dorothy Hunt: Early Links in the Golden Chain of Buddhism Coming West - Patheos - January 7th, 2020
- Tara Goddess of Compassion and Savior of the Suffering - Ancient Origins - January 7th, 2020
- Buddhism and poetry in Japan during the Nara Period - Modern Tokyo Times - January 7th, 2020
- The mysterious Irishman who was the first westerner ordained a Buddhist monk - The Irish Times - January 7th, 2020
- CHINA Sichuan, the government closes a network of Tibetan Buddhist centers - AsiaNews - January 7th, 2020
- After you have a panic attack on live TV, being 10 percent happier is a good start to a changed life - The Boston Globe - January 7th, 2020
- Protection of Sinhala Buddhists will ensure religious freedom - PM - Ceylon Daily News - January 7th, 2020
- The Buddhas Words Open Up Ancient Worlds at the British Library - Tricycle - December 22nd, 2019
- Buddhist Drug and Alcohol Rehab - Addiction Center - December 22nd, 2019
- What Is Buddhism & 6 Meditations To Find Your Zen - YourTango - December 22nd, 2019
- The Gross National Happiness of Bhutan - Geographical - December 22nd, 2019
- Sri Lankan authorities delay on whether to prosecute award-winning writer Shakthika Sathkumara - World Socialist Web Site - December 16th, 2019
- Spot the difference between sign and symbol - The Hindu - December 16th, 2019
- MIT historian Sana Aiyar sheds new light on the complexities of independence movements and global migration - India New England - December 16th, 2019
- Using The Four Noble Truths To Go from Burnout to Bliss - Thrive Global - December 16th, 2019
- The Last Jedi put Star Wars Buddhist philosophy in the foreground - Polygon - December 14th, 2019
- How the Library of Congress Unrolled a 2,000-Year-Old Buddhist Scroll - Atlas Obscura - December 14th, 2019
- Dutch officials after church sale: 'It's better to have Buddhists than apartments' - Crux: Covering all things Catholic - December 14th, 2019
- You probably knew mindfulness could help you with stress. But did you know it could save your marriage? - ABC News - December 14th, 2019
- The Buddhist Kathina Festival - The Good Men Project - December 14th, 2019
- Photos of the Week - Religion News Service - December 14th, 2019
- 'He was like, what?': Why 4 women left their 'normal' lives to become Buddhist nuns - CBC.ca - December 14th, 2019
- Grassroots Buddhism Flourishes in the Outskirts of Bangkok - IDN InDepthNews | Analysis That Matters - December 14th, 2019